- Rick Benattar
- Jack Diamond (segment "MPS")
- David Boreanaz
- Dinner (segment "MPS")
- Patrick Bradley
- The Mime / Vincent / Assistant (segments "MPS" / "The Eggs")
- Kimber Breauxl
- Mother (segment "Vamps")
- Chelsea Dodson
- Daughter (segment "MPS")
- Erik Emmons
- Walt Farberman (segment "Seymour Hackell")
- Tony Ferriter
- Patrick (segment "Overtime")
- Kara Flynn
- Katherine (segment "MPS")
- Robert Harvey
- Dr. Serling (segment "The Eggs")
- Ashley Hill
- Christine Hackell / Waitress / Computer (segments "Overtime" / "Seymour Hackell" / "The Eggs")
- Noah Korda
- Make up Guy (segment "MPS")
- Scott Mabbutt
- Tracy Langan / Self (segment "Overtime")
- Shannon K. MacDonald
- Elizabeth (segments "Overtime" / "MPS")
- Sean Manton
- Tim / The Headless Rider (segment "MPS")
- Kathryn McAlister
- Kathryn (segment "Overtime" / "Vamps")
- Aaron McNally
- Night Guard (special edition segment "Overtime" / "MPS")
- Michael Overton
- Seymour Hackell (segment "Seymour Hackell")
- Albee Patnesky
- Gravedigger / Blues Player (segments "Seymour Hackell" / "The Eggs")
- Stephanie Pinola
- Kate (segment "Overtime")
- Alan Sanborn
- Skyles Horton / Dracula (segments "Seymour Hackell" / "The Eggs")
- Christopher Corey Smith
- Horton (segment "The Eggs")
- Vance Weaver
- Pyrate (segment "Seymour Hackell")
- King Wilder
- Tony (segment "Overtime")
- James Balsamo
- Toxi
