- Noah Sage Anselmo
- Manteo
- JT Atwood
- Ananias Dare
- Ashley Averette
- Fire Dancer
- Emmeline Briggs
- Agona
- Cameron Bryant
- King Wingina
- Joey Cassella
- Sir Walter Raleigh
- Jeffrey B. Duncan
- Old Tom
- Robert Erdman
- Father Martin
- Mallory Green
- Margery Harvie
- Olyvia Gregg
- Queen Elizabeth I
- Emily Hodge
- Dame Colman
- Michael Joseph
- Sentinel
- Kat Littleturtle
- The Storyteller
- Jack Lloyd
- Master of Ceremonies
- Ethan Oxendine
- Wanchese
- Stuart Parks II
- Governor John White
- Jasper Lane Pippin
- Ralph Lane
- Austin Michael Russell
- Captain Barlowe
- Katie Smith
- Fiddler
- Emily Thigpen
- Tavern Keeper
- McKenzie Troyer
- Eleanor Dare
- Charlie Tucker
- Messenger
- Matthew Velez
- Simon Fernando
