- Greg Kriek
- Jack Jefferson
- Pierce Pope
- Young Jack Jefferson
- Jonathan Bergman
- Young James Jefferson
- Dillon Mann
- Bobby Jefferson
- Kareem L. Alston
- Convict
- Mellie Boozer
- Mellie
- Neftali Hernandez
- Bank Teller #1
- Justin Livingston
- Deputy #1
- Brigham McNeely
- James Jefferson
- Marcus Nelson
- Pierre
- Danny M. Gray
- Pastor Danny
- Erica Colson
- Mellie's Mom
- Gianluca DeMary
- Young Bobby Jefferson
- Leander Strauss
- Congregation #1
- Scott Schurmann
- Convict
- Dawn Hopson
- Patty Jefferson
- Faith White
- Young Mellie
- Holden Sky
- Convict
- Robert L. Ballard Jr.
- Bank Patron
- Jerry Hughes
- Convict
- Charlie Moore
- Store Clerk
- Alina Strauss
- Congregation #2
- Michael Wix
- Correctional Officer
- Cindee Smith
- Bank Patron
- Corey Frye
- Greg (Postal Worker)
- Rachael Hollifield
- Bank Patron
- Joseph Juana Robinson
- Convict
- Joseph Robinson
- Convict
