- Anne Bancroft
- Mrs. Robinson
- Dustin Hoffman
- Ben Braddock
- Katharine Ross
- Elaine Robinson
- William Daniels
- Mr. Braddock
- Murray Hamilton
- Mr. Robinson
- Elizabeth Wilson
- Mrs. Braddock
- Buck Henry
- Room Clerk
- Brian Avery
- Carl Smith
- Walter Brooke
- Mr. McGuire
- Norman Fell
- Mr. McCleery
- Alice Ghostley
- Mrs. Singleman
- Marion Lorne
- Miss DeWitte
- Eddra Gale
- Woman on Bus
- Frank Baker
- Hotel Guest
- George Bruggeman
- Church Member
- Garrett Cassell
- Hotel Guest
- Buddy Douglas
- Bellhop in Hotel Lobby
- Richard Dreyfuss
- Boarding House Resident
- Bob Eubanks
- The Newlywed Game Host
- Mike Farrell
- Bellhop in Hotel Lobby
- Bob Folkerson
- Bus Passenger
- Elisabeth Fraser
- Party Guest
- Donald F. Glut
- College Student
- Laurence Haddon
- Mr. Carlson
- Harry Holcombe
- The Minister
- Jonathan Hole
- Mr. Singleman
- Robert P. Lieb
- Mr. Loomis - Party Guest
- Elaine May
- Girl with Note for Benjamin
- Eve McVeagh
- Mrs. Carlson - Party Guest
- Lainie Miller
- Night Club Stripper
- Ben Murphy
- Shaving Fraternity Brother
- Stuart Nisbet
- Birthday Party Guest in Yellow Shirt
- William H. O'Brien
- Hotel Guest
- Sam O'Steen
- Man on Bus
- Robert Perry
- College Student
- Noam Pitlik
- Gas Station Attendant
- Anthony Redondo
- Bus Passenger
- Clark Ross
- Waiter
- Bernard Sell
- Party Guest
- Wayne Stam
- Jeffrey Singleton
- Hal Taggart
- Hotel Guest
- Tim Taylor
- Wedding Guest
- Kevin Tighe
- Carter - Showering Fraternity Brother
- Arthur Tovey
- Hotel Guest
- Eleanore Vogel
- Bus Passenger
- Wally West
- Bus Passenger
- David Westberg
- Valet Parker
- Jay Dee Witney
- Hotel Guest
- Maris Wrixon
- Guest at Welcoming Party
