- Cam Clarke
- Judge / Mr. Santos / Narrator (voice)
- Kenneth Hartman
- Francisco
- Patricia Lentz
- Mary / Woman B (voice) (as Pat Lentz)
- Tress MacNeille
- Lúcia de Jesús Rosa dos Santos / Olimpia de Jesús Marto (voice)
- Kerrigan Mahan
- Police Officer
- Gregory Snegoff
- Lucia's Father
- Kath Soucie
- Jacinta / Lucia's Mother (voice)
- Thomas H. Watkins
- Priest
