- Nicollette Sheridan
- Charlotte Hart
- Bart Johnson
- Daniel Huntslar
- Amanda Foreman
- Pam
- Samantha Hanratty
- Morgan
- Tristan Lake Leabu
- Christopher
- Olympia Dukakis
- Gwen Hollander
- Ian Short
- Reverend Stevens
- Roger Jerome
- Mayor Ramsey
- Nathan Neorr
- Tommy
- Douglas Scott Sorenson
- Rick Buckley
- Leah Roberts
- Carmen
- Darlene Taylor
- Olivia
- Marc Sanders
- Joe
- James Kisicki
- Alan
- Jon Osbeck
- Jerry
- Sam McCabe
- Dylan Turner
- Kevin Crowley
- Dr. Franklin
- Sara Mackie
- Attending Nurse
- Giovanna T. Vitale
- Little Girl
- Radek Lord
- Bully
- Jimmy Townsend
- Electrician
- John Miller
- Santa
- Alec Rommel
- Kid in Hallway
- William Ubbes
- Caroler #1
- Patricia George
- Caroler #2
- Damian Stout
- Caroler #3
- Jaqueline Malisse
- Caroler #4
- Rachel Sachs
- Choir Singer
- Oliver Sheridan
- Oliver the Dog
- Justin Bourne
- Student
- Bill Childers
- Cowboy patron
- Jesse Clark
- Townsperson
- Alan Cupp
- Christmas Tree Lot guy
- Ryan Drake
- Caroler
- Peanut Edmonson
- Poor Kid at toy store window
- Nathaniel Grauwelman
- Hospital Patient
- Bridgette Hudyk
- Background
- Annie Kalahurka
- Poor Mom
- David Kettlehake
- Pedestrian
- Jeff Krebs
- Alan's Executive Assistant
- Michael Loos
- Darren Woods (Dad in hospital)
- Michelle MacCutcheon
- Church Patron
- Leticia Martinez
- Alan's Assistant
- Rodger Pille
- Town Barber
- David Pittinger
- Christmas Tree Buyer
- Derek Polen
- Townsperson
- Laura Robb
- Waitress
- Rick Roberts
- Man buying tree
- Maya Sayre
- Nurse
- Melissa Scalia
- Waitress #2
- Jason Schafer
- Choir
- Josh Tipis
- Townsperson
- William Willet
- Town Business owner
- Kelly Wills
- Townsperson
