- May Robson
- Aunt Marcia Prentiss
- Sybil Jason
- Abigail Prentiss
- Guy Kibbee
- Asa Plunkett
- Jane Bryan
- Betsy Ann Prentiss
- Fred Lawrence
- Tom Squires
- Dick Purcell
- George Chester
- Mary Treen
- Libby
- Gus Shy
- John Scores
- Maude Allen
- Mabel
- Granville Bates
- Sheriff Pengast
- Victor Potel
- Deputy Jake Hutchinson
- George E. Stone
- Steve
- Gordon Hart
- Mayor Bart Cabot
- Tom Wilson
- Bill Brown
- Robert Emmett Keane
- Mister Bridges
- Jack Wise
- Weymouth
- Spec O'Donnell
- Bumpkin
- Fred Trowbridge
- Judge
- Joseph E. Bernard
- Courtroom Spectator
- Hal Craig
- Motorcycle Policeman
- Joseph Crehan
- Frank Knickerbocker - Deputy Coroner
- Joe Cunningham
- Jury Foreman
- Lillian Harmer
- Mrs. Pengast
- Stuart Holmes
- Juror
- Anne O'Neal
- Flora - Telephone Operator
- Jessie Perry
- Juror
- Jacqueline Saunders
- Juror
- Leo White
- Juror
