- Fredric March
- Jean Lafitte
- Franciska Gaal
- Gretchen
- Akim Tamiroff
- Dominique You
- Margot Grahame
- Annette de Remy
- Walter Brennan
- Ezra Peavey
- Ian Keith
- Sen. Crawford
- Anthony Quinn
- Beluche
- Douglass Dumbrille
- Gov. William C.C. Claiborne
- Beulah Bondi
- Aunt Charlotte
- Robert Barrat
- Capt. Brown
- Fred Kohler
- Gramby
- Hugh Sothern
- Gen. Andrew Jackson
- John Rogers
- Mouse
- Hans Steinke
- Tarsus
- Stanley Andrews
- Collector of the Port
- Spring Byington
- Dolly Madison
- Montagu Love
- Adm. Cockburn
- Eric Stanley
- Gen. Ross
- Gilbert Emery
- Capt. Lockyer
- Holmes Herbert
- Capt. McWilliams
- Evan Thomas
- Sir Harry Smith
- Michael Brooke
- Lt. Rogers
- Thaddeus Jones
- John Freeman - a Servant
- Reginald Sheffield
- Ship's Surgeon
- Eugene Jackson
- James Smith - a Servant
- Davison Clark
- Col. Butler
- Ivan Miller
- Commodore
- Louise Campbell
- Marie de Remy
- John Hubbard
- Charles
- Evelyn Keyes
- Madeleine
- Lina Basquette
- Roxanne
- Luana Walters
- Suzette
- Barry Norton
- Villere
- Alex Hill
- Scipio
- George Reed
- Nicodemus - a Servant
- Alphonse Martell
- Maj. Latour
- Frank Melton
- Lt. Shreve
- Ted Oliver
- Fish Hook
- Avril Cameron
- Mrs. Claibourne
- Florence Wix
- Mrs. Livingston
- Richard Denning
- Capt. Reid
- J.P. McGowan
- Jailer
- John A. Milton
- Banjo Player
- Francis McDonald
- Camden Blount
- Frank Abbott
- Pirate
- Pearl Adams
- Praline Seller
- Rafael Alcayde
- (uncredited)
- Richard Alexander
- Pirate
- Demetrius Alexis
- (uncredited)
- Paulita Arvizu
- French Woman
- Hooper Atchley
- (uncredited)
- Arthur Aylesworth
- Pirate
- Lynn Bailey
- (uncredited)
- Granville Bates
- Gentleman Wanting to Surrender
- Hank Bell
- Pirate
- Eumenio Blanco
- Servant
- Stanley Blystone
- Pirate
- Marie Bodie
- Spanish Woman
- Nina Borget
- Passenger
- Barlowe Borland
- Dolly Madison's Servant
- Ed Brady
- Jackson's Aide
- Charles Brokaw
- Vincent Nolte
- Horace G. Brown
- Pirate
- James Burke
- Pirate
- Tom Burke
- Pirate
- Marie Burton
- (uncredited)
- Mae Busch
- (uncredited)
- A.S. 'Pop' Byron
- Victory Ball Guest
- George Calliga
- (uncredited)
- Edward Cecil
- (uncredited)
- Lane Chandler
- Pirate
- André Cheron
- French Merchant
- Ethel Clayton
- Woman Selecting Perfumes
- Jack Rube Clifford
- Mountaineer
- James Craig
- Victory Ball Creole Guest
- Richard Cramer
- Pirate
- Floyd Criswell
- Pirate
- Dorothy Dayton
- (uncredited)
- Victor De Linsky
- Pirate
- Martial de Serrand
- (uncredited)
- Paula DeCardo
- (uncredited)
- Jack Deery
- Highlander Officer
- Amapola Del Vando
- Spanish Woman
- Vic Demourelle
- Pirate
- Jane Dewey
- (uncredited)
- Jimmy Dime
- Shirtless Pirate
- Al Downing
- Pirate
- Ellen Drew
- (uncredited)
- Jimmie Dundee
- Pirate
- Yvonne Duval
- (uncredited)
- Paul Ellis
- Spanish Man
- Charles Emerson
- Clerk at Claiborne's Office
- Margaret Fealy
- Elderly Woman
- Maude Fealy
- Wife
- Antonio Filauri
- Customer
- Paul Fix
- Dying Pirate
- James Flavin
- British Sergeant
- Ray Flynn
- Maj. Hinds
- Diana Forest
- (uncredited)
- J.C. Fowler
- Prominent Gentleman
- Jerry Frank
- Shirtless Sailor
- Blanche Franke
- French Woman
- Curt Furberg
- Passenger
- Norah Gale
- (uncredited)
- George Ghermanoff
- (uncredited)
- Kenneth Gibson
- (uncredited)
- Lupe González
- Wife
- Grace Goodall
- Dolly Madison's Dinner Guest
- Rita Gould
- (uncredited)
- William Gould
- Victory Ball Guest
- Mildred Gover
- Colored Girl
- Rosita Granada
- Passenger
- Jesse Graves
- Majordomo
- Jennifer Gray
- (uncredited)
- Lorna Gray
- (uncredited)
- Harriette Haddon
- (uncredited)
- Wilfred Halroyd
- Swordsman
- Chuck Hamilton
- Pirate
- Ray Hanford
- Pirate
- Lillian Harmer
- Woman Who'll Lock Up Chicken Coop
- Winifred Harris
- (uncredited)
- Carey Harrison
- Courier
- John Hart
- (uncredited)
- Ivo Henderson
- Flag Bearer
- Oscar 'Dutch' Hendrian
- Pirate
- Ben Hendricks Jr.
- Pirate
- Leyland Hodgson
- British Naval Lieutenant
- Beulah Hutton
- (uncredited)
- Charles Irwin
- Highlander
- Tiny Jones
- Pirate's Wife
- Jane Keckley
- Wife
- Crauford Kent
- Victory Ball Guest
- Gwen Kenyon
- (uncredited)
- Bob Kortman
- Pirate
- Frank Lackteen
- Pirate
- Alexander Leftwich
- (uncredited)
- Edward LeSaint
- Gentleman Willing to Fight
- Carl M. Leviness
- Dolly Madison's Dinner Guest
- Ralph Lewis
- Prominent Gentleman
- Baron James Lichter
- Pirate
- Leota Lorraine
- (uncredited)
- Helen Lutrell
- Dolly Madison's Dinner Guest
- Jack Maclennan
- (uncredited)
- Andre Marsaudon
- Guest
- Lita Marty
- (uncredited)
- Margarita MartÃn
- Wife
- Francisco Marán
- Guest
- Joyce Mathews
- (uncredited)
- Eric Mayne
- Party Guest
- William McCall
- Ship's Officer
- Philo McCullough
- Assistant Jailer
- Carmelita Meek
- Wife
- John Merkyl
- Officer
- John Merton
- Pirate Shot by Lafitte
- Robert Milasch
- Pirate
- Ernesto Molinari
- (uncredited)
- Monte Montague
- Pirate
- Francisco Moreno
- Abbe Duberg
- Philip Morris
- Pirate
- Charles Morton
- (uncredited)
- Henry Mowbray
- Artillery Captain
- John Nasborough
- Pirate
- Louis Natheaux
- Prominent Gentleman
- Ottola Nesmith
- Dolly Madison's Dinner Guest
- Ralph Norwood
- (uncredited)
- Kanza Omar
- (uncredited)
- George Owen
- Infantry Captain
- Rita Owen
- Wife
- John Patterson
- Young Blade
- Edward Peil Sr.
- Victory Ball Guest
- Yvonne Pelletier
- Wife
- Jack Pennick
- Bucktoothed Private
- Albert Petit
- Passenger
- Albert Pollet
- Guest
- Lee Prather
- Legislator
- Pete Rasch
- Pirate
- Ione Reed
- Wife
- Suzanne Ridgway
- (uncredited)
- Jimmy Robinson
- Poster Boy
- Ruth Robinson
- (uncredited)
- Dorothy Rogers
- Wife
- Constantine Romanoff
- Pirate in Jail
- Buddy Roosevelt
- Officer
- Alma Ross
- (uncredited)
- José Rubio
- Spanish Man
- Mel Ruick
- Pirate with Violin
- Jack Rutherford
- Orderly
- George Savidan
- French Newsboy
- Cy Schindell
- Pirate
- Louise Seidel
- (uncredited)
- Walter Shumway
- (uncredited)
- Gertrude Simpson
- Wife
- Robert St. Angelo
- Pirate
- Edwin Stanley
- Dolly Madison's Dinner Guest
- Eddie Sturgis
- Officer
- John M. Sullivan
- Colonel
- John Sutton
- British Officer Before Battle
- Libby Taylor
- Madeleine's Mammy
- Terry
- Landlubber
- Bob Terry
- Officer
- Laura Treadwell
- Charming Lady
- Charles Trowbridge
- Daniel Carroll
- Archie Twitchell
- Party Guest
- Virginia Vale
- (uncredited)
- Foy Van Dolsen
- Mountaineer
- Richard Van Opel
- Troop Captain
- Jacques Vanaire
- French Man
- César Vanoni
- (uncredited)
- Trina Varella
- (uncredited)
- Blanca Vischer
- (uncredited)
- Bess Wade
- Wife
- William Wagner
- Officer
- Bruce Warren
- Ship's Purser
- Peggy Watts
- (uncredited)
- Stanhope Wheatcroft
- (uncredited)
- Dorothy White
- (uncredited)
- Gloria Williams
- (uncredited)
- Maston Williams
- Pirate
- Gilbert Wilson
- (uncredited)
- Douglas Wood
- Gentleman Wanting to Surrender
- Harry Woods
- American Sergeant
- Charlotte Wynters
- Charming Southern Lady
