- Jarrod Crooks
- Chris
- Scott Brault
- Santa
- Erin Antilla
- Jen
- Casper King
- Ned
- Randy Vongphakdy
- Flynn
- Jonathan Aldrich
- Barnaby
- Katherine Antilla
- Coin Payer
- Georgia Arnold
- Child
- Indiana Arnold
- Everett
- Nevada Arnold
- Child
- Sara Atkinson
- Mall Manager
- Kremena Bujanowski
- Secretary
- Garrett Michael Cameron
- Office Worker 4
- Kellie Cameron
- Office Worker 3
- Colin Chaput
- Concerned Boy / Child (voice)
- Alex Collins
- Sledding Boy
- Kylie Collins
- Sledding Girl
- Justin Crooks
- Dewey
- Zac Daniels
- Cash Payer 3
- Joseph Facente
- Sketching Co-Worker
- Chad Franzen
- TV Weather Man
- Bella Gajewski
- Child
- Eric Hall
- Ziggy
- Julie Hatlestad
- Happy Co-Worker
- Drew Hauser
- Child
- Tia Jeanius
- Office Worker 6
- Harleen Kedrowicz
- Little Girl
- Kayla Knuth
- Screaming Elf
- Brian Kowalski
- Cash Payer 2
- Gregory Kuper
- Mall Security
- Josh Kurth
- Elf 2
- Liam Lafave
- Crying Baby
- Wil Loper
- Tall Elf 1
- Cole Meyer
- Cash Payer 1
- Kevin Meyer
- Crazy Elf
- Sandra Meyer
- Mary
- Kaylee Pecha
- Excited Mom
- Doug Phillips
- Mall Santa
- Sebastian Pruitt
- Office Worker 5
- Bruce Purcell
- Frank
- Lauren Rosemurgy
- Mall Elf
- Jocelyn Sanchez
- Hange / Child (voice)
- Maya Sanchez
- Child
- Nate Shallue
- Tall Elf 2
- Logan John Shewmake
- Child
- Cole Thorson
- Office Worker 1
- Elise White
- Office Worker 2
- Andy Zynda
- Busker
- Andrew Stecker
- Thompson
