- Mike Akers
- Pete Daily
- Brandon Bell
- Jack Perry
- Nico Bell
- Self - town resident
- Steven Michael Bell
- Self - town resident
- Terri Bisgrove
- Mae Coleman
- Richard Buathier
- Ralph Wiley
- Ember Burns
- Mary Lane
- Dylan Francis Calvi
- Drug user / Murdered Dad / Arresting Detective
- Mark Carder
- Self - town resident
- Debi Christo
- Self - town resident
- Doug Christo
- Self - town resident
- Patrick Conley
- Pence
- Shawn Conner
- Self - town resident
- Rick Davis
- Pence Patron
- J.J. Deville
- Self - town resident
- Bob Elardo
- Self - town resident
- Lorinda Valetta Elardo
- Self - town resident
- Logan Fry
- John Petersen
- Tim Hale
- Bill Harper
- B.J. Halsall
- Judge
- Collin Johnson
- Jimmy Lane
- Hayley Johnson
- Self - town resident
- Matt Kane
- Detective Erikson
- Dianna Kaufman
- Concerned Neighbor
- Christina Conrad Keenan
- Self - town resident
- Chad Knauer
- The Newscaster
- Crissy Kolarik
- Murdered Mom
- Chris Kraft
- Self - town resident
- Jimmie Lee
- Self - town resident
- Mia Mae Lynne
- Self - town resident
- Keith Munden
- Detective Akin
- Tommy Murphy
- Mr. Wayne
- Pauline Nowakowski
- Mrs. Lane
- Tim Pence
- Pence Patron
- Jonathan Plummer
- Himelf - Arresting Detective
- Rick Plummer
- Arresting Detective / Interrogator
- Matt Price
- Self - town resident
- Austin Rospert
- Clyde Perkins
- Andrew Santa
- Killer Teenager
- Marissa Semon
- Blanche
- Jacob Southwick
- Self
- Alicia Marie Spurlock
- Elizabeth
- Jaylen Stoneburner
- Kayden
- Angela Vassalle
- Boss
- Erik William
- Dr. Alfred Carroll
- Diana Lee Woody
- Kayden's Mom
