- Vincent Price
- Locke / Fortunato Luchresi / Ernest Valdemar
- Maggie Pierce
- Lenora (segment "Morella")
- Leona Gage
- Morella (segment "Morella")
- Peter Lorre
- Montresor (segment "The Black Cat")
- Joyce Jameson
- Annabel (segment "The Black Cat")
- Basil Rathbone
- Carmichael (segment "The Case of M. Valdemar")
- Debra Paget
- Helene (segment "The Case of M. Valdemar")
- David Frankham
- Dr. James (segment "The Case of M. Valdemar")
- Lennie Weinrib
- Policeman (segment "The Black Cat")
- Wally Campo
- Barman Wilkins (segment "The Black Cat")
- Alan DeWitt
- Chairman of Wine Society (segment "The Black Cat")
- John Hackett
- Policeman (segment "The Black Cat")
- Edmund Cobb
- Driver (segment "Morella")
- Scott Brown
- Servant (segment "The Case of M. Valdemar")
- Benjie Bancroft
- Wine Society Member (segment "The Black Cat")
- Paul Bradley
- Wine Society Member (segment "The Black Cat")
- Kenneth Gibson
- Wine Society Member (segment "The Black Cat")
- Kenner G. Kemp
- Wine Society Member (segment "The Black Cat")
- Jack Kenny
- Tavern Patron (segment "The Black Cat")
- Cosmo Sardo
- Wine Society Member (segment "The Black Cat")
- Jack Tornek
- Wine Society Member (segment "The Black Cat")
