- Steve Monroe
- Mailman Henry
- Gavin Wilde
- Cowboy Kid
- Landon Gordon
- Kid on Bike
- Hope Banks
- Mrs. Pendalton
- Karimah Westbrook
- Mrs. Mayers
- James Handy
- Mayor Billings
- Mather Zickel
- James
- Josh Meyer
- Freddy (Housing Planner)
- Vince Cefalu
- Chuck
- Michael D. Cohen
- Stretch
- Corey Allen Kotler
- Bomber
- Leith M. Burke
- Mr. Mayers
- Julianne Moore
- Rose / Margaret
- Noah Jupe
- Nicky
- Tony Espinosa
- Andy Mayers
- Alex Hassell
- Louis
- Matt Damon
- Gardner
- Glenn Fleshler
- Sloan
- Steven Shaw
- Doctor Jennings
- Don Baldaramos
- Reverend Jones
- Gary Basaraba
- Mitch
- Ellen Crawford
- Eileen
- Cathy Giannone
- Sylvia
- Megan Ferguson
- June
- Allan Wasserman
- Roger
- Mark Leslie Ford
- Bill Thackery
- Nancy Daly
- Linda (Gardner's Secretary)
- Richard Kind
- John Sears
- Robert Pierce
- Ed Pappas
- Pamela Dunlap
- Mrs. Krup
- Jack Conley
- Hightower
- Frank Califano
- Father Dominicus
- Lauren Burns
- Cindy (Mitch's Secretary)
- Biff Yeager
- Mr. Karger
- Oscar Isaac
- Bud Cooper
- Benjamin Franczuszki
- Reporter
- Peggy Miley
- Betty (Interviewee)
- Brady Allen
- DeLuca
- Blake Altounian
- Frog
- Inbal Amirav
- Church Choir Singer
- Erik Aude
- Riot Cop
- Gia Balzano
- Mississippi Younger Daughter
- Avery Barkdull
- Grocery Store Kid
- Steven T. Bartlett
- Bus Driver
- Tim Beaufoy
- Protester
- Ross Bechtold
- Ohio Dad
- Becca Beton
- New York Girl
- Nicholas W. Bishop
- Neighbor / Protester (uncredited)
- Julian R. Booth
- Protestor
- Andrew Boyle
- Clinic Doctor
- Kayden Bracken
- Baseball Player
- Sommer Branham
- Neighbor / Protester (uncredited)
- Matthew Broadley
- Town Hall Teen
- Bobby Brodney
- Reporter
- Stephen Brown
- Bill
- Benjamin Burt
- Town Hall Protestor
- Paul Cartwright
- Neighbor / Protestor (uncredited)
- Saraya Chanadet
- Ohio Daughter
- Owen Conway
- Town Hall Protester
- Diane Dehn
- Virginia
- Alessandro Delpiano
- Townhome kid
- Gretchen Dickason
- Passersby
- Josh Dunn
- Baseball Player #14
- Brandon Duracher
- Fireman
- Sylvia Dyson
- Bus Passenger Behind Driver
- Nichole Eberle
- Neighbor / Protester (uncredited)
- Jon Eiswerth
- Clinic Dad
- Dean England
- Funeral Mourner
- Mary Beth Eversole
- Neighbor
- Marah Fairclough
- Shopping Woman
- Sebastian Feldman
- Police Officer
- Jack Fisher
- Collins
- Jared Fleming
- Neighbor / Protestor (uncredited)
- Jessee Foudray
- Clinic Nurse / Neighbor (uncredited)
- Paul Riley Fox
- Soldier
- Chrystall Friedemann
- Neighbor Lady
- Laura Kranz Galvan
- Grocery Shopper
- Brian Gilbert
- Mover #2
- Anna Gion
- Smoking Pregnant Woman
- Matthew Godfrey
- Protester
- Ian Gooch
- Neighbor / Protester (uncredited)
- Alexandra Goodman
- Margaret's Neighbor
- Emily Goss
- Clinic Mom
- Damon Gravina
- Bus Passenger
- Ashley Haden
- Neighbor / Townsperson (uncredited)
- Cooper Harman
- Baseball Player
- Rod Harrel
- Passerby
- Carter Hastings
- Peterson
- Chris Highlands
- Rowdy Neighbor
- Eric Hinwood
- Neighbour / Protestor (uncredited)
- Max Hoffmann
- Neighbor / Protestor (uncredited)
- Tim Hooper
- Policeman
- Ryan Izay
- Neighbor
- Tomas Johansson
- Police Sergeant
- Larry Justice
- City Councilman
- Ori Kalmus
- New York Dad
- Rachel Karp
- Neighbor
- Hugh Kennedy
- Town Hall Protester
- Chris Kerner
- Fireman
- Riggsby Lane
- Neighbor / Protestor (uncredited)
- Matt Laydon
- Newscaster
- Alex Leontev
- News Reporter
- Alex Lizotte
- Young Hoodlum / Protester (uncredited)
- Jamie Love
- Fireman
- John Macey
- Fat Man with Drum
- Samuel Marcus
- Young Hood / Town Hall Teen (uncredited)
- Joel Mathews
- Neighbor
- Diana Matlak
- Funeral Mourner
- Valeriya Matveeva
- Shopper
- George Todd McLachlan
- Georgie
- Lauren Mendoza
- P & S Secretary
- Emily Merlin
- Neighbor
- Johnny Meyer
- Mr. Pendelton
- Dominic Michael
- Angry Neighbor
- Katie Michels
- Ohio Mom
- Kevin Mick
- Tow Truck Driver
- Rene Montague
- Neighbor
- Joshua Edward Moore
- Fireman Bill
- Megan Moran
- Funeral Mourner
- Weston Mueller
- Perp #1
- William Myers
- Townsperson
- Jean Nasser
- Baseball Player
- Tim Neff
- Protestor #4
- Brett Newton
- Racist Neighbor
- Trevor Thomas Olwig
- Neighbor / Protestor (uncredited)
- Josh Opper
- Neighbor
- Tommy Otis
- Angry Neighbor
- Wes Overby
- Neighbor / Protestor (uncredited)
- Rick Papandrea
- Town Hall Protester
- Jake Parrish
- Construction Worker
- Laura Penn
- Hospital Nurse
- Michael Perez
- Thumper
- Paul Pikus
- Town Hall Welcomer
- Steven M. Porter
- Newell
- Harlan Post
- Angry Neighbor
- John Potter
- Neighbor / Protester (uncredited)
- Taylor Ragan
- Mississippi Mom
- Emmie Ray
- Neighbor
- Dana Rosendorff
- Neighbor
- Douglas Rouillard
- Angry Neighbor
- Emily Cathrine Rutan
- Esthetician
- Joseph Sanfelippo
- Announcer
- Jeffrey Scott Basham
- Neighbor #1
- Angus Sepenuk
- Billy
- David Otto Simanek
- Neighbor
- Terry F. Smith
- Line Up Perp #1
- Nathan D. Snyder
- P & S Employee
- Andrew Stiko
- Police Officer
- Danielle Stout
- Neighbor / Protester (uncredited)
- John Kyle Sutton
- Sousafone Player / Angry Neighbor (uncredited)
- Logan Swearingen
- Clinic Boy
- Andrew Sykes
- Bobby
- Daniel Teleky Toth
- Pvt. Clark National Guard
- Matt Valvardi
- Angry Neighbor
- Brian VanGeem
- Neighbor / Protester (uncredited)
- Andrew Varenhorst
- Perp
- Jakob Verweij
- Little League Baseball Player
- Riley Warmoth
- Town Hall Protestsor
- Marshall Watson
- Office Executive
- Connor Wilks
- Neighbor / Protester (uncredited)
- Jade Willey
- Mississippi Dad
- Dash Williams
- Walters
- Shannen Elise Wilson
- Crossing School Girl
