- Doug Walker
- Nostalgia Critic / Ask That Guy With the Glasses / Chester A. Bum / Link
- Lindsay Ellis
- Nostalgia Chick / Arwen
- Lewis Lovhaug
- Linkara / King Arthur
- Noah Antwiler
- The Spoony One / The Gatecleaner / Housewife / Gandalf
- Brad Jones
- Cinema Snob / Indiana Jones
- Joe Vargas
- Angry Joe / Inigo Montoya
- Phelan Porteous
- Phelous / Rockbiter
- Benjamin Daniel
- Benzaie / Conan the Barbarian
- Allison Pregler
- Obscurus Lupa / Snow White
- Kaylyn Saucedo
- MarzGurl / San (as Kaylyn Dicksion)
- Bennett White
- Bennett the Sage / Aslan
- Mathew Buck
- Film Brain / Harry Potter
- Kinley Mochrie
- Luke Mochrie / Harry Potter (as Luke Mochrie)
- Justin Carmical
- JewWario / Jareth
- Paul Schuler
- Paw / Profion
- Todd Nathanson
- Todd in the Shadows / Dread Pirate Roberts
- Thomas Hanley
- Handsome Tom / Willow
- Mickey Paradis
- 8-Bit Mickey / Peter Pan
- William DuFresne
- That Dude in Suede / An Obstacle (as Will Dufrense)
- Orlando Belisle
- Malachite
- Holly Christine Brown
- Witness
- N. Cardena
- Witch Warrior
- Bhargav Dronamraju
- Ma-Ti
- Elisa Hansen
- House Owner
- Brian Heinz
- Cloak #1 / The Last Angry Geek
- Antonella Inserra
- BFF Nella
- James Jarosz
- Cloak #2
- Briana Laws
- Daughter
- Jori Laws
- Angry Mother
- Dayna Munday
- Angry Woman
- Dave Myers
- Cat / Puppeteer
- Jason Pullara
- Krom
- James Rolfe
- Voice of the Ancient World
- Elizabeth Skochil
- Cloak #3
- Jim Troken
- Driver
- Barney Walker
- Larry Prince
- Rob Walker
- Chuck Jaffers
- James Warren
- Jaffers' Roommate
- Michael Michaud
- Guy on the Street
