- Dennis Quaid
- John Bouchart
- Nick Offerman
- Jerry Kane
- Jacob Tremblay
- Joe Kane
- Martha Plimpton
- Lesley Ann
- Nancy Travis
- Patty Bouchart
- Thomas Mann
- Adam Bouchart
- Jade Fernandez
- Brenda Reese
- Jobie James
- Casino Guest
- Barry Clifton
- Judge Tate
- Eric Parkinson
- Father Michael
- Chris Greene
- Officer Wray
- Tommy Kramer
- Tommy Paulson-Audience member #3
- Buddy Campbell
- Bob-Audience member #1
- Julia D. Borkowski
- Graduation Guest
- Ben Matias
- Restaurant Patron
- Ruby Wolf
- Jess Bouchart
- John Trejo
- Rodney
- Nathan Kirby
- Feautered Background
- Marilyn Knapp
- Neighbor
- Bobby Gilchrist
- Mr. Friedman
- Alonso Rappa
- Teen #3
- Andrew Ortenberg
- Courtroom Clerk
- Faron Ledbetter
- State Trooper
- Krishna Sistla Ward
- Clerk
- Terry J. Nelson
- Deputy Sheriff
- Mark Alan Jaeger
- Meeting Hall Attendee
- Brittany Seals
- Mourner
- Jason Scott Morgan
- Ponytail
- Julia Watts
- Registrar
- Gabe Williams
- Police Recruit
- Brandon Stewart
- Rob Everson
- Leslie Dianne
- Courtroom Gallery Audience Member
- Phoenix Ghost
- Motel 6 Manager
- Vu Ha
- Deputy Sheriff
- Brandon Devine
- Police Recruit
- John Potthast
- Detective
- Kyleigh Box
- Grocery Store Shopper
- Ed LaCerra
- Background / Extra
- Bradley Hall
- Detective background
- Rachel Chapko
- Welvern's Employee
- Kezia DaCosta
- Candace Jeffers
- Patchez Black
- Meeting Hall #4 Attendee
- Matthew Jaycox
- State Trooper
- Robert Mayfield
- Restaurant Patron #1
- Andrew Blair
- Police Recruit
- Tara Hollums
- Funeral attendant
- Kivet Conner
- Police Recruit
- Rick W. Stiles
- Mourner / Friend (uncredited)
- Laura Welkey
- School Staff
