- Gary Cooper
- Michael 'Nuggin' Taylor
- George Raft
- Powdah
- Frances Dee
- Margaret Tarryton
- Henry Wilcoxon
- Lieutenant Stanley Tarryton
- Harry Carey
- Captain of 'William Brown'
- Olympe Bradna
- Babsie
- Robert Cummings
- George Martin
- Porter Hall
- Court Prosecutor
- George Zucco
- Barton Woodley
- Virginia Weidler
- Tina
- Joseph Schildkraut
- Gaston de Bastonet
- Gilbert Emery
- Captain Martisel
- Lucien Littlefield
- Toymaker
- Paul Fix
- Violinist
- Tully Marshall
- Pecora
- Monte Blue
- Mate
- Stanley Fields
- Captain Paul M. Granley
- Norman Ainsley
- Ticket Taker
- Stanley Andrews
- First Mate
- Gertrude Astor
- Barmaid
- Agnes Ayres
- Minor Role
- Baby Peggy
- Minor Role
- Robert Barrat
- The Reverend
- Lina Basquette
- Brunette in Saloon
- Wilson Benge
- Doctor
- Frank Benson
- Gardener
- George Beranger
- Ship's Officer
- Arthur Blake
- Prime Minister
- Eddie Borden
- Friend of Gastonet
- Fritzi Brunette
- Minor Role
- Allan Cavan
- Dignitary
- Davison Clark
- Bailiff
- Harvey Clark
- Court Clerk
- Ethel Clayton
- Passenger
- Herbert Clifton
- Ticket Clerk
- David Clyde
- Butler
- G. Pat Collins
- Slaver
- Clyde Cook
- Hendry - Coachman
- Margaret Daggett
- Minor Role
- J. Gunnis Davis
- Barber
- Lillian Dean
- Minor Role
- Jimmy Dime
- Sailor / Prisoner (uncredited)
- Lowell Drew
- Jury Foreman
- Franklyn Farnum
- Court Bailiff
- Martin Faust
- Minor Role
- Leslie Francis
- Woolsey's Secretary
- Phyllis Godfrey
- Housemaid
- Mary Gordon
- Cook
- Pauline Haddon
- Blonde
- Grayce Hampton
- Old Knitting Woman
- Beth Hartman
- Minor Role
- Forrester Harvey
- Pub Proprietor
- Edward Hearn
- Courtroom Spectator
- Fay Holden
- Mrs. Martin
- Olaf Hytten
- Proprietor
- Virginia Kami
- Minor Role
- Jane Keckley
- Minor Role
- Colin Kenny
- Military Guard
- Crauford Kent
- Navy Clerk
- Erin La Bissoniere
- Minor Role
- Alan Ladd
- Sailor
- Rollo Lloyd
- Parchy
- Betty Lorraine
- Minor Role
- George MacQuarrie
- Doctor
- Lon McCallister
- Cabin Boy
- Charles Middleton
- Jury Foreman
- Henry Mowbray
- Bus Man
- Forbes Murray
- Associate Justice
- Carlyle O'Rourke
- Puppeteer
- Ted Oliver
- Minor Role
- Earl Pingree
- Minor Role
- Alonzo Price
- Minor Role
- Dick Rich
- Minor Role
- Constantine Romanoff
- Pub Drinker
- Don Rowan
- Minor Role
- Francis Sayles
- Minor Role
- Rolfe Sedan
- Friend of Gastonet
- Lee Shumway
- Mate
- Phillips Smalley
- Dignitary
- William Stack
- Judge
- Paul Stanton
- Defense Attorney
- John M. Sullivan
- Dignitary
- Ben Taggart
- Ship's Officer
- Colin Tapley
- Donaldson
- Harry Tenbrook
- Lifeboat Crewman
- Jameson Thomas
- Pelton
- Edward Van Sloan
- Ship's Officer
- Dorothy Vernon
- Passenger
- Luana Walters
- Eloise
- Paul Walton
- Puppeteer
- Robert Warwick
- Vice Admiral
- Blue Washington
- Ship Slave
- Jane Weir
- Barmaid
- Gloria Williams
- Passenger
