- Christine Lakin
- Lucy Hart
- Dean Cain
- Sheriff Rick Langston
- Sophie Bolen
- Alana Hart
- Joel Paul Reisig
- Deputy Tom Brookfield
- Janet Caine
- Diane Langston
- Mandalynn Carlson
- Kara Langston
- Teri Lee
- Sylvia
- DJ Perry
- Evan Ward senior
- Derek Brandon
- Evan Ward junior
- Linda Boston
- Deputy Shirley LaMarche
- Mark Boyd
- Raynor Jeffries
- Joseph Scott Anthony
- Neighbor / Elf
- Franco Pulice
- Frederico
- James Cowans
- Mr. Harold
- Joe Anderson
- Pastor
- Paul Hopper
- Santa Claus
- Emily Foster
- Angel
- Rebekah Hughes
- Wendy Brookfield
- Jettzen Shea
- Bratty Kid in Church
- Westin Whitaker
- Christopher Brookfield
- Paul Tierney
- Sean
- George Francisco
- Dream Santa 2
- Kraig Haybarker
- Dream Santa 5
- Ted Flynn
- Dream Santa 1
- Rickey Lee Maynard
- Dream Santa 3
- Josealyn Pontius
- Shepherd with sheep
- Elizabeth Foster
- Elizabeth / Neighbor's daughter / Wise Man
- Riley Snider
- Joseph
- Hadley Whitaker
- Young Alana
- Thea Baird
- Egg Nog Lady
- Gabby Snider
- Wise Man
- Kim Crozier
- Lisa / Sean's Mom
- Lydia Rinzler
- Waitress
- Emma Markosky
- Shepherd
- Karrie Noble
- Church Attendee / Towns Person
- Jacqueline VanVugt
- Youth Group leader
- Abby Rinzler
- Mary
- Robert Garrison
- Dream Santa 4
- Jon Erich Booth
- Answering machine
- Dui
- Max the Police Dog
- Clair VanElderen
- Young Sophie
- Tatum E. Konecsni
- Shepherd
- Jonathon Foster
- Wise Man
- Rachel Markosky
- Inn Keeper
- Meghan Duffy
- Neighbour Kate
- Dominic Joseph Nepa
- Church attendee
- Jason M. Varso
- Towns person
