- Aaron Yoo
- Max
- Alex Solowitz
- Drew
- Brennan Murray
- Cashier
- Brian Kubach
- Joe Stunner
- Brit Morgan
- Carly
- Charlie Sheen
- Charlie Sheen
- Curt Lowens
- Grandpa Arnie
- Debra Jo Rupp
- Ruth Baum
- Delfina Alden
- Natasha
- Machete Bang Bang
- Max's Squeeze
- Ellen Albertini Dow
- Grandma Elma
- Hilary Duff
- Kim Powers
- Ida Darvish
- Helen
- Janna VanHeertum
- Bar Wench
- Jillian Barberie
- Barbara Bernhardt
- Joel Michaely
- Lloyd
- Johnny Messner
- John McCartney
- Josh Gad
- Sam Baum
- Joshua LeBar
- Richard
- Kristen Ruhlin
- Sammy Kingston
- Louise Linton
- Jessica
- Melonie Diaz
- Gwen
- Michael Leone
- Noah
- Paul Raci
- Paparazzi
- Sean Ross
- Box Office Manager
- Shannon Theule
- Nate
- Teddy Lane Jr.
- Tyson
- Wayne Knight
- Walter Baum
- Daniel Nguyen
- Surprise Party Guest
- Tyler Barnes
- Best Friend
- Michael Beardsley
- Nerdy Man
- Marisa Baram
- Sam's Ex #2
- Dmitriy Kazakov
- Broadway Audience
- Jeremiah Gallagher
- L.A. Pedestrian
- Rubén Navarro
- Cloaked Killer
- Chelsea Bellas
- Night Club Goer
- Maya Benten
- Asian Babe
- Jessica Bishop
- LA Pedestrian
- Kyra Boff
- NY Pedestrian
- Jenifer Brougham
- Surprise Party Friend
- Heather Callahan-Stevens
- Mara
- Timm Carney
- Theater Goer
- Alexander Cooper
- Night Club Goer
- Kate Rees Davies
- Restaurant Patron
- Angelina Duplisea
- Heavy Set Woman
- Bruce Wayne Eckelman
- John's Dad
- Annie McCain Engman
- Surprise Party Friend
- Jayne Entwistle
- Excited Kim Powers Fan
- Kyle Fields
- NYC Bar Patron
- Charlie Glackin
- Theater Goer / Jogger
- Joost Griffioen
- Broadway Audience
- Mary Jo Gruber
- Sam's Ex #16
- Lindsay May Heathcote
- Tori
- Charlene Hiestand
- John's Patient
- Nathan Holder
- Theater Goer
- James Howarth
- Mathew
- Kevin Huie
- Movie Theater Audience
- Rachel Johanson
- NY Pedestrian
- Heidi Kerring
- Kim's Friend #2
- Abdur Rahim Khan
- Old Man
- Raef Lawson
- Alan
- Sarah Leners
- Sam's Ex #6
- Matt Lubin
- Tommy
- Catherine Masters
- Sam's Ex #12
- Ciara McAvoy
- Party Goer
- Danae McKillop
- Lanky Woman
- Jim Medcraft
- Night Club Goer
- Mandi Mellen
- Sam's Ex #7
- Melody Rose Morales
- Anne
- Allyson Morgan
- NY Pedestrian
- Cat Navarro Lee
- Sam's Ex #9
- Sloan O'Neal
- Veronica
- Devi Ohira
- Sam's Ex #10
- Adam Pearce
- Bar Jabroni #5
- Tony Petkovich
- Lawrence
- Ryan Gregory Phillips
- Surprise Party Friend
- Megan Lee Pyle
- Night Club Goer
- Michelle Ramos
- Club Goer
- Bria Roberts
- Drew's Drunk Girl (Maria)
- Amanda Robins
- Surprise Party Guest
- Anne Rosell
- Surprise Party Guest
- Julie Rothman
- Sam's Ex #14
- Jaimie Sagoskin
- Starstruck Waitress
- Chantay Sherrer
- Party Goer
- Collin Alfredo St. Dic
- AF. AM. Dude
- James Stolk
- Broadway Audience
- Sasha Stuber
- Sam's Ex #4
- Siavash Tofighi
- Surprise Party Guest
- Stephanie Walters
- Amanda
- Melanie Booth
- Ashley Ayers
- Clive Castle
- Chris
- Vanessa Knight
- Tori
- Aurora Maria Lopez
- Kelly
- Julia Louiza
- Miranda
- Joanna Mahaffy
- Amy
- Kristi Manna
- NY Pedestrian
- Naomi Melton
- Surprise Party Guest
- Shelbi Sexton
- Club Goer
- Charlene Yang
- Mayumi
