- Guy Madison
- Marshal James Butler 'Wild Bill' Hickok
- Andy Devine
- Aloysius P. 'Jingles' Jones
- Kristine Miller
- Cindy Howard
- Richard Avonde
- Dick Howard
- John Crawford
- King Bradshaw
- Tristram Coffin
- Mr. Otis, Lawyer
- Edward Clark
- Grandpa Jeb Randall
- Reed Howes
- Mr. Slate, Stagecoach Line Owner
- Wade Crosby
- Mr. Canfield, Mine Owner
- Bobby Jordan
- Sandy Smith
- Jane Adams
- Peggy
- Riley Hill
- Smoke Signal Outlaw
- William Haade
- Tony, Stagecoach Guard
- I. Stanford Jolley
- Henchman
- Bill Hale
- Henchman
