- David Ackroyd
- Self - Narrator
- Allen Brenner
- Robert Cobb Kennedy, Plot to Burn NY
- Mike Brown
- Lt. Prentiss, Mosby's Fairfax Raid
- Gerald Chance
- Co-conspirator, Plot to Burn NY
- Mark Chipps
- Col. Robert Johnstone, Mosby's Fairfax Raid
- Jim Choate
- Col. Sir Percy Wyndham, Mosby's Fairfax Raid
- Michael L. Colosimo
- William Pittenger, The Great Locomotive Chase
- Kathryn Coombs
- Extra, Plot to Burn NY
- Emmanuel Dabney
- Head to camera historian, Petersburg segment
- Buddy Garrett
- James Andrews, Great Locomotive Chase; extra, Plot to Burn NY, Mosby's Fairfax Raid
- Kurt Grauf
- Co-conspirator, Plot to Burn NY Segment
- Marc A. Hermann
- Head to camera historian, Plot to Burn NY
- Christopher Keenan
- NYC Criminologist
- Bill McIntosh
- Co-conspirator, Plot to Burn NY
- Jared Morrison
- Union General Ormsby MacKnight Mitchell - The Great Locomotive Chase
- Erika Onsager
- Mrs. Robert Johnstone, Mosby's Fairfax Raid, extra, Plot to Burn NY
- Russ Richards
- Gen. Edwin Stoughton, Mosby's Fairfax Raid
- William L. Scott
- Mosby Ranger, Mosby's Fairfax Raid
- Jeffrey F. Smith
- John Singleton Mosby, Mosby's Fairfax Raid
- Pat Sullivan
- James "Big Yankee" Ames, Mosby's Fairfax raid
- James Thompson
- William Fuller, Great Locomotive Chase
- Kirkland Wohlrab
- Extra, Plot to Burn NY
- Stephen Wolfsberger
- Head to camera historian, Union guard (Mosby's Fairfax Raid)
- Scott Zeiss
- Co-conspirator, plot to Burn NY
