- Lance B. Witmer
- Robin Hood
- David Griffith
- Sheriff of Nottingham
- Josh Fulmer
- Sir Guy of Gisborne
- Joshua Rawleigh
- Allan-a-Dale
- Julien Mathus
- Friar Tuck / Soldier
- Grant Shaika
- Will Scarlet
- Ethan Feiler
- Little John
- Collin Hickerson
- Phillip-a-Bland
- Jaden Bria
- Sir Simon De Belleme
- Nate McKeever
- Mudge
- Jon Davis
- Merry Man
- Joel Diller
- Merry Man / Soldier
- Paul Stoltzfus
- Tom Wheatly
- Logan Livengood
- Bill Stutley
- Clark Newswanger
- Merry Man
- Cassidy Witmer
- Knight on Horseback
- Carli Cochran
- Knight on Horseback
- Emily Conrad
- Knight on Horseback
- Hannah Smith
- Knight on Horseback
- Aaron Smith
- Soldier
- Samantha Ingram
- Soldier / Villager (as Sam Ingram)
- Owen Witmer
- Squire
- Elijah Hershey
- Soldier
- Josiah Hershey
- Blacksmith
- Ty Godfrey
- English Guard
- Seth Walker
- Jack the Jailor
- Stephen Shaika
- Executioner / Woodchopper
- Jordan Donaldson
- Soldier
- Mark Hoffer
- Soldier
- Lizzy Schell
- Sheriff's Wife
- Jess Fisher
- Peasant Woman
- Kaela Witmer
- Villager
- Julia Kuro
- Villager
- Cassidy Ingram
- Maken
- Jeff Cosgrove
- Victim
- Kyle Martin
- Soldier
- Daniel Schaeffer
- Soldier
- Josh Beiler
- Soldier
