- Aric Diamani
- Aric
- Ryan Satterfeal
- (as Nicholas Scott)
- Patrick Garrigan
- Crash Cop
- Alex Dittmer
- Chief Hicks
- Marc Wilkinson
- High School Crowd Guy
- Gina Palmer
- Beverly Swell
- Alejandro Marin
- Anarchy Kids' Hostage
- Tyler Amm
- Richard
- Caylee Bourdoin
- Mr. J's Cashier
- Katie Ocepeck
- Hick Gang
- Zach Shaw
- Deputy 1
- Pam McFarland
- Derby Girl
- Trent Zelko
- Brad Gelp
- Dan Churney
- Pastor Carafe
- Denzil Longville
- Robber
- Sean Urbanc
- Deputy 4
- Kyle Wilkinson
- Deputy 3
- Dakota Hungerford
- Anarchy Kid
- Terri Baxter
- Derby Girl
- Season Chandler
- Derby Girl
- Madison Burress
- Anarchy Kid
- Matthew Birtell
- Hick Gang
- Morgan Foster
- Baptized Boy
- Shannon Cantu
- Baptized Girl
- Claire Centko
- Derby Girl
- Rachel Johnson
- Spencer
- Emily Swain
- Riley
- Jake Newman
- Derby Boy
- Samantha Winnicki
- Baptized Disciple
- Kelly Johnson
- Mayor Webster
- Jami Valenzuela
- Baptized Boy
- Nathan Torres
- Hick Gang
- Braeden Bend
- Anarchy Kid
- Evan Morency
- Robber
- Pawel Kaniewski
- Deputy 2
- Zander Dziedzic
- Anarchy Kids Leader
- Simon Tiffin
- Baptized Disciple
- Serena Armstrong
- Baptized Girl
- Amber Wheeler
- Derby Girl
- Stormy Plunk
- Baptized Disciple
- Giuseppe Urso
- Marc
- Jennie Carpenter
- Crash Cop
- Linda Walter
- Baptized Girl
- Trevor McCandless
- Doug
- Clarissa Gerrard
- Charlie
- Ashley Keegan
- Kennedy
- Xochytl Cantu
- Baptized Boy
- Matthew Najdanovich
- Runaway Officer
- Lena Orwig
- Grocery Store Cashier
- Jesus Santoy
- Mr. J's Worker
- Patrick Sullivan
- Baptized Disciple
- Nick Coglianese
- Mr. J's Worker
- Cameron Dryer
- Baptized Boy
- Orion Lovell
- Darren
- Jeorge Galvez
- Steve
- Traci Willet
- Hick Gang
- Charles Mitchell
- Gary
