- Ray Milland
- Eric Yeager
- Jan Sterling
- Polly Sickles
- Gene Lockhart
- Thaddeus J. Banner
- William Frawley
- Len Sickles
- Elsie Holmes
- Myra Banner
- Taylor Holmes
- P. Duncan Munk
- Willard Waterman
- Orlando Dill
- Henry Slate
- Dud Logan
- James Griffith
- Ogelthorpe 'Oggie' Meadows
- Jim Hayward
- Doom
- Donald MacBride
- Pheeny
- Hal K. Dawson
- Mr. Fisher
- Orangey
- Rhubarb
- Brooks Benedict
- Dill's Lawyer #1
- Sedal Bennett
- Minor Role
- Edward Biby
- Weather Forecaster
- Billie Bird
- Mona Lizzie
- Larry J. Blake
- Police Radio Voice
- Madge Blake
- Mrs. Emily Thompson
- Oliver Blake
- Cadaver Jones
- Herman Boden
- Photographer
- Gail Bonney
- Woman with Dog
- John Breen
- Western Union Boy
- Joe Brooks
- Courtroom Spectator
- Ralph Brooks
- Dill's Lawyer #2
- Morgan Brown
- Baseball Game Spectator
- Joseph Bryan
- Radio Announcer
- Charles Campbell
- Announcer
- Douglas Carter
- Newspaper Reporter
- Harry Cheshire
- Mr. Seegle - Board Member
- Edward Clark
- Judge Loudermilk
- Tristram Coffin
- Dr. Henry J. Stillman
- James Conaty
- Sporting Goods Store Customer
- Jack Daly
- Officer
- Mike Donovan
- Bartender
- Paul Douglas
- Man on Park Bench
- Jimmie Dundee
- Pencil Louie's Driver
- Al Ferguson
- Policeman in Garden
- Charles Ferguson
- Baseball Player
- Frank Fiumara
- Baseball Player
- James Flavin
- O'Leary, Manhattan Police Chief
- Howard Gardiner
- Bailiff
- Adda Gleason
- Maid
- Roy Gordon
- Golfer
- Sandra Gould
- Housewife Bettor
- Joe Gray
- Baseball Player
- Mack Gray
- Suspect in Polo Coat in Line-Up
- Don Haggerty
- Policeman
- Chuck Hamilton
- Detective
- Tom Hanlon
- Radio Announcer
- Buck Harrington
- Proprietor
- Hans Herbert
- Doctor
- F. Herrick Herrick
- Newspaper Reporter
- Stuart Holmes
- Golfer
- Wally Hood
- Umpire
- Jerry James
- Policeman
- Curtis Jarrett
- Minor Role
- Dolly Jarvis
- Photographer
- Richard Karlan
- Pencil Louie
- Harold J. Kennedy
- Sporting Goods Salesman
- Donald Kerr
- Taxi Driver
- Michele Lange
- Newspaper Reporter
- Grace Lenard
- Kitty
- Arthur Lovejoy
- Minister
- Wilbur Mack
- Golfer
- George Magrill
- Policeman at Ballpark
- Strother Martin
- Michael 'Shorty' McGirk
- Edwin Max
- Fish Eye
- Paul Maxey
- Mr. Reese - Board Member
- Stanley McKay
- Newspaper Reporter
- William Meader
- Photographer
- Lee Miller
- Baseball Player
- Rex Moore
- Caddy
- Howard Negley
- Process Server
- Leonard Nimoy
- Young Baseball Player
- Will Orlean
- Hoodlum
- Stanley Orr
- Newspaper Reporter
- Ruth Packard
- Minister's Wife
- Jack Perry
- Baseball Game Spectator
- Sam Pierce
- Barber
- Joe Ploski
- Henchman
- Hilda Plowright
- Katie
- Anthony Radecki
- Baseball Player
- Roberta Richards
- Reporter
- Ralph Sanford
- Eddie - Brooklyn Police Chief
- Carl Saxe
- St. Louis Baseball Player
- Frank J. Scannell
- Hamburger Harry - Bookie
- Charles Sherlock
- Court Clerk
- George Sherwood
- Mr. Thompson
- Bert Stevens
- Baseball Game Spectator
- Jack Stoney
- Henchman
- Charles Sullivan
- Fan with Binoculars
- Frank Sully
- Big Head Charlie - Bookie
- Gus Taillon
- Sexton
- Joseph Terry
- Caddy
- William Thourlby
- Baseball Player
- Harry Varteresian
- Elbert
- Dorothy Vernon
- Baseball Game Spectator
- Sailor Vincent
- Baseball Game Spectator
- Billy Wayne
- St. Louis Manager
- Ben Welden
- Oily Moe - Bookie
- Eric Wilton
- Golfer
- Hank Wise
- Baseball Pitcher
- Douglas Wood
- Mr. Carroll - Board Member
