- Asta Paredes
- Chrissy Goldberg
- Catherine Corcoran
- Lauren
- Zac Amico
- Zack
- Vito Trigo
- Leonardo
- Lloyd Kaufman
- Lee Harvey Herzkauf
- Babette Bombshell
- Principal Westly
- Tara E. Miller
- Rachel Ruysch
- Mike Baez
- Donatello
- Mark Quinnette
- Michaelangelo
- Jim Sheppard
- Raphael
- Reiki Tsuno
- Rembrandt
- Josh Potter
- Kevin the Duck Monster / Jock
- Clay von Carlowitz
- Eugene 'The Machine' McCormack
- Lauren Sylvester
- Eugene's Tranny Friend
- Stefan Dezil
- Slater
- Gabriela Fuhr
- Kelly
- Adam P. Murphy
- Mr. Chips
- Brenda Rickert
- Aunt Bee
- Debbie Rochon
- Coach Kotter
- Ron Mackay
- Coach Sandusky
- John Patrick Brennan
- Jeffrey the Hazmat Goon
- Patrick Klouman
- Teenie Weenie
- Ken Cosentino
- Ricky Retardo
- Baird Hageman
- Tristan
- Lemmy
- The President
- Greg Hinaman
- Blind Security Guard
- Arlowe Price
- Jiggles the Juggalo
- Stuart Kiczek
- Hurley
- Colin Reboy
- Colin
- Ron Jeremy
- God
- Mark Torgl
- School Janitor
- Corrado Adamo
- Italian Meltdown Boy / Tromaville High Student
- Alex Aronson
- Jock
- Zack Beins
- Comic Con Nerd 2
- Alexandra Bodenhorn
- Tongue Rip Girl
- Bob Bozek
- Named Him Randall
- Blade Braxton
- Motorcycle Cretin
- Lori Brown
- News Reporter
- Heather Cahill
- Shower Girl
- Travis Campbell
- Self
- Meg Carriero
- Asian School Girl
- Scotty Catuzza
- Factory worker
- Dedderz
- Themselves
- William Dreyer
- Arnold / Deeper Throat
- Monique Dupree
- Shower Girl
- Michael J. Epstein
- Herzkauf Monster
- Sheri Fairchild
- Teacher tromaville high
- Mark Finch
- News Reporter
- Nicola Fiore
- Ms. Bigguns
- Joe Fleishaker
- Lauren 6 months later
- Erika Frase
- Tromaville High Cheerleader
- Rob Gabriele
- Cretin
- Ed Gage
- Tromaville High Student
- Marcus Ganci-Rotella
- Tromaville Citizen
- Bjarni Gautur
- Scrätch
- Dylan Mars Greenberg
- Tromaville High Student
- Steven Haar
- Stevo the Devo
- Michael Hawerbier
- Reporter
- Teresa Hui
- Zac's Rejection Girl
- Aaron Jordan
- Tromaville Citizen
- Charlotte Kaufman
- Audrey Benjamin
- Lisbeth Kaufman
- Tromaville High Student
- Patricia Kaufman
- Self
- DanÃel GrÃmur Kristjánsson
- Blue Lagoon Meltdown Boy
- René Krzok
- German Reporter / Herzkauf Monster Victim
- Kayla Lanzalaco
- Tromaville Citizen
- Ed Larson
- Dr. Jack Swinney
- Jeff Lasky
- Worker #2
- Stan Lee
- Narrator
- Scud Lightning
- Herzkauf Monster / Radical Dude
- Justin A. Martell
- Barry Jennings
- Brandy Mason
- Shower Girl Brandy
- Ben McBride
- Comic Con Laser Victim
- Collette Mclafferty
- Wheels the Roller Girl
- Dominic Mendez
- Tromaville Citizen
- Mark Mendola
- Teacher
- John Migliore
- Tromaville Citizen
- Smokey Miles
- Count Smokula
- James Murray
- Chuck Flingus
- Karl Myles
- Extra
- Sarah Nowak
- Bloody Mess
- Mick O'Keefe
- Motorcylce Gang Member / Teacher / Parent / Factory Worker
- Purple Pam
- Bollywood Dancer
- Mark Parker
- Band Geek
- Rhonda Parker
- Punk
- Kellen Pembleton
- Tromaville High Student
- Shawn C. Phillips
- Comic Con Nerd 3
- Kenneth Powell
- Teacher
- Nico Praz
- Tromorganic Burger Victim
- Sam Qualiana
- Bully
- Kyle Rappaport
- Dead Tromaville High Student
- Tabetha Ray
- Mocking Bitch
- Joseph Reboy
- Teacher
- Liam Regan
- Looks Like A Dick
- James Rolfe
- The Angry Video Game Nerd
- Ivana Ruegg
- Tromaville Citizen
- Doug Sakmann
- Flag Cretin / Sgt. Kabukiman N.Y.P.D.
- Michael C. Schmahl
- Factory Worker #1
- Thomas Edward Seymour
- Teacher
- Myron Smith
- Tromaville Citizen
- Jeff Soster
- Tromaville Citizen
- Corina Taylor
- Tro-Gasm Girl
- Richard Taylor
- Comic Con Nerd 1
- Michael Varrati
- Bread Burns
- Julian Walker
- The Toxic Avenger
- Katie Weremblewski
- Tromaville Citizen
- Nadia White
- Shower Girl
- Henry Zebrowski
- Chet Boden
- Michael Zsiros
- Dead Teacher
- Manek Deboto
- Australian Meltdown Boy
- John Hadity
- Health Inspector
- Bailey Jay
- Cameo
- Nuke Puke 'Em
- Australian Meltdown Girl
