- Mike Starr
- Burglar
- Paul Herman
- Burglar
- Don Pardo
- 'Guess That Tune' Host
- Martin Rosenblatt
- Mr. Needleman
- Helen Miller
- Mrs. Needleman
- Danielle Ferland
- Child Star
- Julie Kavner
- Tess, the mother
- Julie Kurnitz
- Irene
- David Warrilow
- Roger
- Wallace Shawn
- Masked Avenger
- Mick Murray
- Avenger Crook
- William Flanagan
- Avenger Announcer
- Seth Green
- Joe
- Michael Tucker
- Martin, the father
- Josh Mostel
- Abe
- Renée Lippin
- Ceil
- William Magerman
- Grandpa
- Leah Carrey
- Grandma
- Joy Newman
- Ruthie
- Hy Anzell
- Mr. Waldbaum
- Judith Malina
- Mrs. Waldbaum
- Dianne Wiest
- Bea
- Fletcher Previn
- Andrew
- Oliver Block
- Nick
- Maurice Toueg
- Dave
- Sal Tuminello
- Burt
- Rebecca Nickels
- Evelyn Goorwitz
- Mindy Morgenstern
- 'Show & Tell' Teacher
- David Mosberg
- Arnold
- Ross Morgenstern
- Ross
- Kenneth Mars
- Rabbi Baumel
- Andrew B. Clark
- Sidney Manulis
- Mia Farrow
- Sally White
- Lee Erwin
- Roller Rink Organist
- Roger Hammer
- Richard
- Terry Lee Swarts
- Nightclub Customer
- Margaret Thomson
- Nightclub Customer
- Tito Puente
- Latin Bandleader
- Denise Dumont
- Latin singer 'Tico-Tico no Fubá'
- Dimitri Vassilopoulos
- Perfirio
- Larry David
- Communist Neighbor
- Rebecca Schaeffer
- Communist's Daughter
- Belle Berger
- Mrs. Silverman
- Guy Le Bow
- Bill Kern
- Brian Mannain
- Kirby Kyle
- Stanley Burns
- Ventriloquist
- Todd Field
- Crooner
- Peter Lombard
- Abercrombie Host
- Martin Sherman
- Mr. Abercrombie
- Crystal Field
- Abercrombie Couple
- Maurice Shrog
- Abercrombie Couple
- Marc Colner
- Whiz Kid
- Roberta Bennett
- Teacher with Carrot
- Joel Eidelsberg
- Mr. Zipsky
- Danny Aiello
- Rocco
- Peter Castellotti
- Mr. Davis
- Gina DeAngeles
- Rocco's Mother
- Shelley Delaney
- Chekhov Actress
- Dwight Weist
- Pearl Harbor Announcer
- Ken Levinsky
- USO Musician
- Ray Marchica
- USO Musician
- Jeff Daniels
- Biff Baxter
- J.R. Horne
- Biff Announcer
- Kuno Sponholz
- German
- Henry Yuk
- Japanese
- Sydney Blake
- Miss Gordon
- Kitty Carlisle
- Radio Singer
- Robert Joy
- Fred
- Henry Cowen
- Principal
- Philip Shultz
- Whistler
- Mercedes Ruehl
- Ad Man
- Bruce Jarchow
- Ad Man
- Greg Gerard
- Songwriter
- David Cale
- Director
- Ira Wheeler
- Sponsor
- Hannah Rabinowitz
- Sponsor's Wife
- Edward S. Kotkin
- Diction Teacher
- Ruby Payne
- Diction Student
- J.E. Beaucaire
- Diction Student
- Paul Berman
- 'Gay White Way' Announcer
- Richard Portnow
- Sy
- Tony Roberts
- 'Silver Dollar' Emcee
- Barbara Gallo
- Dance Palace Musician
- Jane Jarvis
- Dance Palace Musician
- Liz Vochecowizc
- Dance Palace Musician
- Ivan Kronenfeld
- On-the-Spot Newsman
- Frank O'Brien
- Fireman
- Yolanda Childress
- Polly's Mother
- Artie Butler
- New Year's Bandleader
- Diane Keaton
- New Year's Singer
- Gregg Almquist
- Radio Voice
- Jackson Beck
- Radio Voice
- Wendell Craig
- Radio Voice
- William H. Macy
- Radio Voice
- Ken Roberts
- Radio Voice
- Norman Rose
- Radio Voice
- Kenneth Welsh
- Radio Voice
- Sandy Dell
- Crying Woman
- Woody Allen
- Joe, the Narrator
- Bonnie Lee Bakley
- (uncredited)
- David Bickford
- Silver Dollar Assistant
- Thomas Brogan
- Navy Officer
- Kitty Felde
- Mrs. Riley
- Marie Gabrielle
- Young Sailors Wife
- Carson Grant
- Sailor in Coney Island bumper car
- Zach Grenier
- Audience Member
- Ron Leir
- Radio Actor
- George Maniere
- Guess That Tune Trumpet Player in Band
- J.B. McNeely
- Sailor
- Fred Melamed
- Bradley
- Scott Meyer
- Classroom student
- Mark Patterson
- Nightclub Orchestra Trombonist
- Maurice Peress
- Conductor in 'Guess That Tune' Scene
- Ilana Rapp
- Counter Girl
- Tommy Roeder
- Gym Trainer
- Ruth Rugoff
- Rita
- Christine Scheier
- (uncredited)
- Hester Schell
- Girl at the Cafe
