- Sean Penn
- Henry 'Hopper' Nash
- Elizabeth McGovern
- Caddie Winger
- Nicolas Cage
- Nicky / Bud
- John Karlen
- Mr. Nash
- Rutanya Alda
- Mrs. Nash
- Max Showalter
- Mr. Arthur
- Crispin Glover
- Gatsby Boy
- Barbara Howard
- Gatsby Girl
- Bob Maroff
- Al
- Dominic Nardini
- Soldier with Annie
- John Brandon
- Mr. Kaiser
- Eve Brent
- Mrs. Kaiser
- Suzanne Adkinson
- Sally Kaiser
- Shawn Schepps
- Gretchen
- Charles Miller
- Arnie
- Patricia Allison
- Mrs. Spangler
- Al Hopson
- Elmer
- Ted Grossman
- Skating Soldier
- Scott McGinnis
- Michael
- Brian Trumbull
- Kid in Skating Rink
- Kate Williamson
- Mrs. Winger
- Julie Philips
- Alice Donnelly
- Fielding Greaves
- Mr. Donnelly
- Arnold Johnson
- Tattoo Artist
- Kevin Fraser
- Marine
- Gerry Gibson
- High School Principal
- Page Hannah
- High School Girl
- Shane Kerwin
- R.D.
- Jonathan Charles Fox
- Arnold Billings
- Michael Madsen
- Frank
- Dana Carvey
- Baby Face
- Victor Rendina
- Mr. Luzzato
- Rebecca Pollack
- Girl in Bowling Alley
- Victor Paul
- Pool Hall Barman
- Lou Butera
- A Pool Player
- Michael Talbott
- Bill
- Phil Adams
- Bill's Shipmate
- Chuck Picerni Jr.
- Bill's Shipmate
- Philip Romano
- Bill's Shipmate
- Arlin Miller
- Minister at Funeral
- Jan Rabson
- Sailor
- Walter Mathews
- Sailor
- Carol Kane
- Annie
- David Avne
- Bowling Alley Army Patron
- Bill Baker
- Bowling Alley Patron
- Richard Calkin
- Bit Part
- Steven Lambert
- Bit Part
- Patrick McGaughy
- Bit Part
- Michael Schoeffling
- Amputee Soldier
