- Andrew Sensenig
- David Peterson
- Bryan Christopherson
- Michael Peterson
- Andrew James Anselmo
- Chad Peterson
- Melody Brooke
- Nancy Peterson
- Josh Durham
- Wayland
- Nicole Smith
- Kathy Peterson
- Bob Carter
- Detective Brett Haverty
- Brad Hartliep
- Tye Majors
- Frank Ford
- Detective Jonathan Spire
- Heather Okun
- Angela
- Michael Clemons
- Miguel
- Tim Taylor
- Jailer
- Sherri Small Truitt
- Crime scene CSI chief
- Frankie von Stein
- Randy
- Michael Austin Parker
- Kevin
- Margaret Sanchez
- School dean
- Jessica McBride
- Buon Giorno waitress
- Richard L. Olsen
- Sheriff's deputy
- Kevin 'The Voice' White
- Lead singer
- Kristin Colaneri
- News reporter
- Lucinda May
- Police secretary
- Stewart Matthews
- Attorney
- Megan Adelle
- Jailer
- Matt Bailey
- Crime scene lead officer
- Travis Britton
- Ben
- Daniel Chamero
- Redneck sidekick
- Brett Hardin
- CSI Agent
- Ray Nicholas Hosack
- Police Officer
- Morgan Luce
- Holly
- John P. McGrath
- SWAT team sergeant
- Esteban Peña
- Officer
- Jay Prichard
- Minister
- Kristi Sensenig
- Receptionist
- Craig Simons
- Crime Scene Officer
- Misty Simons
- Legal Secretary
