- Hayley Mills
- Pollyanna
- Jane Wyman
- Aunt Polly
- Richard Egan
- Dr. Edmond Chilton
- Karl Malden
- Reverend Paul Ford
- Nancy Olson
- Nancy Furman
- Adolphe Menjou
- Mr. Pendergast
- Donald Crisp
- Mayor Karl Warren
- Agnes Moorehead
- Mrs. Snow
- Kevin Corcoran
- Jimmy Bean
- James Drury
- George Dodds
- Reta Shaw
- Tillie Lagerlof
- Leora Dana
- Mrs. Paul Ford
- Anne Seymour
- Mrs. Amelia Tarbell
- Edward Platt
- Ben Tarbell
- Mary Grace Canfield
- Angelica
- Jenny Egan
- Mildred Snow
- Gage Clarke
- Mr. Murg
- Ian Wolfe
- Mr. Neely
- Nolan Leary
- Mr. Thomas
- Edgar Dearing
- Mr. Gorman
- Don Ames
- Townsman
- Frank Baker
- Townsman
- Cathy Ann Bisutti
- Girl Singing 'America the Beautiful'
- Paul Cristo
- Townsman
- Jack Deery
- Townsman
- Paul Frees
- Barker
- Richard George
- Young Man at Fairground
- Stephanie Gorman
- Girl Singing 'America, America'
- Tim Graham
- Orphanage Worker
- Signe Hack
- Townswoman
- Harry Harvey
- Editor
- Susie Hawkins
- Visitor on staircase
- Harvey Karels
- Party Guest
- Jon Lormer
- Mr. Geary
- Arthur Lovejoy
- Townsman
- Anastasia Kostoff Mann
- Orphan
- Hans Moebus
- McEnerney, Dress Shop Manager
- William Newell
- Mr. Hooper
- Jean Ransome
- Townswoman
- Fred Rapport
- Townsman
- Charles Seel
- Train Conductor
- George Sowards
- Wagon Driver
- David Swift
- Fireman
- Arthur Tovey
- Fishing Booth Attendant
