- Liz Days
- Â Tammy Lawn 23 episodes, 2013-2015
- Susannah Jones
- Â Gwendolyn / ... 22 episodes, 2013-2015
- Lynn Berg
- Â Todd Lawn / ... 21 episodes, 2013-2015
- Stephan Amenta
- Â Matthew Lawn 18 episodes, 2013-2015
- Marie Cecile Anderson
- Â Amber / ... 15 episodes, 2013-2015
- Linda Elizabeth
- Â Chloe 14 episodes, 2013-2015
- Ray Bergen
- Â Congregant / ... 14 episodes, 2013-2015
- Peggy Queener
- Â Paulette Whack 8 episodes, 2014-2015
- Sam Salter
- Â Congregant 5 episodes, 2013-2014
- Marc Balfour
- Â Sam 5 episodes, 2015
- Jay Palmieri Jr.
- Â Pastor / ... 4 episodes, 2014-2015
- Katie Meador
- Â Congregant / ... 4 episodes, 2014
- Aryana Fernando
- Â Congregant / ... 4 episodes, 2014
- Carolyn Popp
- Â Bag Lady 4 episodes, 2015
- Lauren Marcus
- Â Delilah 3 episodes, 2014
- Natasha Murray
- Â Sassy Congregant / ... 3 episodes, 2014
- Gregory Levine
- Â Competition Attendant / ... 3 episodes, 2014
- David Sitler
- Â Chad 3 episodes, 2015
- Katy Frame
- Â Dawn 3 episodes, 2015
- Carol Sims
- Â Congregant 2 episodes, 2013-2014
- Arlene Moskowitz
- Â Competition Attendant 2 episodes, 2014
- Linda Wartenweiler
- Â Pastor's Wife 2 episodes, 2014
- Mary Anderson
- Â Competition Attendant 2 episodes, 2014
- Natasha Hanina
- Â Bouncy Woman 2 episodes, 2014
- Elizabeth Bukhari
- Â Congregant 2 episodes, 2014
- Jenny Diaz
- Â Congregant 2 episodes, 2014
- Samia Mounts
- Â Dominatrix 2 episodes, 2015
- Jenny Moss
- Â Clubgoer / ... 2 episodes, 2015
- Stacy Osei-Kuffour
- Â Judge #2 1 episode, 2014
- Melanie Brook
- Â Hot Girl with Boyfriend 1 episode, 2014
- Helene Macaulay
- Â Judge #1 1 episode, 2014
- Brett Pruneau
- Â Hot Boy with Girlfriend 1 episode, 2014
- Kate Fitzgerald
- Â Customer 1 episode, 2014
- Johnny Serret
- Â Bartender 1 episode, 2015
- Derya Celikkol
- Â Congregant 1 episode, 2015
- Ryan Black
- Â Officer 1 episode, 2015
- Victoria Prather
- Â Congregant 1 episode, 2015
- Courtney Latrice
- Â Congregant 1 episode, 2015
- Isabella Way
- Â Clubgoer 1 episode, 2015
- Rosalie Tenseth
- Â Officer 1 episode, 2015
- Tavi Juarez
- Â Congregant 1 episode, 2015
- Lisa Budwig
- Â Clubgoer 1 episode, 2015
- Jenny Ward
- Â Tiny Witch 1 episode, 2015
- Yolanda Hamilton
- Â Congregant 1 episode, 2015
- Brianna Pete
- Â Clubgoer 1 episode, 2015
- Denise Ivanoff
- Â Clubgoer 1 episode, 2015
- Josue B. Infante
- Â Congregant 1 episode, 2015
- Rebecca Edmonson
- Â Clubgoer 1 episode, 2015
- Kaylan Pedine
- Â Congregant 1 episode, 2015
- Robin Lawrence Jones
- Â Congregant 1 episode, 2015
- Lisa Bellan-Boyer
- Â Congregant 1 episode, 2015
- Lulu Bundra
- Â Clubgoer 1 episode, 2015
- Mary Jo Kosempa
- Â Congregant 1 episode, 2015
- Polly Reavis
- Â Congregant 1 episode, 2015
- Lanier Westmoreland
- Â Congregant 1 episode, 2015
- Ricky McCreadie
- Â Clubgoer 1 episode, 2015
- Carol Sims
- Â Congregant unknown episodes
