Cast
- Mary Martin
- Peter Pan
- Cyril Ritchard
- Mr. Darling / Captain Hook
- Lynn Fontanne
- Narrator
- Maureen Bailey
- Wendy / Jane
- Margalo Gillmore
- Mrs. Darling
- Sondra Lee
- Tiger Lily
- Joe E. Marks
- Smee
- Norman Shelly
- Nana / Crocodile
- Joey Trent
- John
- Kent Fletcher
- Michael
- Jacqueline Mayro
- Liza
- Edmund Gaynes
- Slightly
- Bill Snowden
- Curly
- Carson Woods
- Nibs
- Benedict Herrman
- First Twin
- Luke Halpin
- Second Twin
- David Komoroff
- Tootles
- Richard Wyatt
- Lion
- Joan Tewkesbury
- Ostrich
- Peggy Maurer
- Wendy Grown-up
- John Holland
- Black Bill
- Robert Vanselow
- Starkey
- Richard Winter
- Cecco
- George Zima
- Kangaroo
- Frank Lindsay
- Pirate
- Frank Marasco
- Pirate
- Arthur Partington
- Pirate
- Jim Sisco
- Pirate
- Kirby Smith
- Pirate
- John Smolko
- Pirate
- Arthur Tookoian
- Pirate
- James B. Welch
- Pirate
- Linda Dangcil
- Indian
- George Lake
- Indian
- Lisa Lang
- Indian
- Diki Lerner
- Indian
- Annabelle Lyon
- Indian
- Robert Piper
- Indian
- Suzanne Rivera
- Indian
- Anne Wallace
- Indian
- Jerry Johnson
- Pirate
Music Department
- Louis Adrian
- conductor / musical director
- Ray Barr
- music coordinator
- Elmer Bernstein
- composer: incidental music
- Peter Howard
- assistant to conductor / musician: Tinker Bell
- John Lesko
- conductor
- Trude Rittman
- composer: incidental music
- Albert Sendrey
- orchestrator
Additional Crew
- Larry Elikann
- technical director (as Lawrence Elikann)
- Peter Foy
- flying effects supervisor
- Rick Kelly
- production associate
- Jerome Robbins
- choreographer
- Marcia Kuyper Schneider
- associate director (as Marcia Kuyper)
- Don Shirley
- additional scenery (as Don Shirley Jr.)
