- Sarah Nicklin
- Sister Wrath
- Alexandra Cipolla
- Sister Pride
- Shanette Wilson
- Sister Lust
- Ruth Mahala Sullivan
- Sister Gluttony
- Brandon Luis Aponte
- Richie Corbucci
- Michael Reed
- Jesus / The Devil
- Rich Tretheway
- Momma Rizzo
- David Lavallee Jr.
- Viper Goldstein
- Sarah Lewis
- Mother Superior of St. Vrains
- Nolan Kerr
- Father O'Bannon
- Andre Boudreau
- Lucky
- Daniel Lee White
- Paulie
- Ricardo Rebelo
- Vincent
- Jason McCormick
- Father Thomas
- Alex Aponte
- Detective Vargas
- David Erin Wilson
- Sam
- Irina Peligrad
- Sister Envy
- Mark Debenedictis
- Cheech
- Kenneth Koury
- Bobo
- John Sheppard
- Father Jacob Michaels
- John Joseph Gomes
- Gandhi
- Mark Carter
- The Naughty Priest
- Luis Brandon Aponte
- Oscar
- Debbie Rochon
- Mother Superior
- Lloyd Kaufman
- The Pope
- Lilith Astaroth
- Go-Go Dancer
- Bill Jacques
- Coke Snorting Mobster
- Tyrone Alcorn
- Strip Club Manager
- Jay Walker
- Married Strip Club Patron
- George Raynor
- Strip Club Patron
- Jim Powers
- Drunk Mobster #1
- John Boitano
- Gut Toting Mobster
- Monika Reed
- Top Secret Nun #1
- Lori Vought-Nicklin
- Top Secret Nun #2
- Dan Leuevre
- Cardinal
- Alexandra Johnson
- Sister Sappho
- Nathan A. Quattrini
- Mohawk Punk / Levi Bronowitz
- A.J. Paratore
- Large Punk / Eli Bronkowitz
- George W. Aldrich II
- Sleazy Pimp
- D.J. Joker
- Nun Heaven MC
- Tony Milano
- Special Needs Man
- Ted Marr
- Demon Ninja
- Sonya Joyner
- Sycophant Nun
- Michael Bilow
- Moses
- Tony Nunes
- Medical Examiner
- William G. Monterroso
- Police Photographer
- Paul Querceto
- Chicken Mobster
- Peter Morse
- Meatball Mobster
- Stefano
- Chest Wound Mobster
- Ricky Spriano
- Face Wound Mobster
- Chris Boucher
- Bruno Cozzi
- David L. Tamarin
- Lucio Bava
- Bernard Larrivee Jr.
- Sunglasses Mobster
- Michael Gagan Jr.
- Lou the Boxer
- Jake Brederson
- Gym Manager
- Tony Jones
- Bar Nun Bouncer
- Lee Ann Wilber
- Broken Bottle Nun
- Khym Carmichael
- Jesus Christ Nun
- Mello Desire
- Vomiting Nun
- David Anatasi
- Detective Larry
- Robert Jude Buco
- Officer Cappicolla
- Margaret Wolf
- Gun Check Nun
- Billy Joe Moretti II
- Bar Nun Band Member
- Jennifer Scharf
- Hooker Haven Madam
- Brian Matus
- Well-Dressed Pimp
- Joel Richards
- The Easter Bunny
- Tiny the Terrible
- Police Informer
- Richard Griffin
- God
- David Adams Murphy
- Mario
- Theresa Dern
- Nun
- Suzanne England
- Nun Heaven Nun #1
- Regina Gadoury
- Nun
- Aurora Grabill
- Hooker
- Jeffery Kincannon
- Mobster
- Josh Lawton
- Actor
- Mauricio Merino Jr.
- Oscar
- Tanya Smith
- Nun
- Julia Wolin
- Nun
