- Linda Black
- Usherette
- Alan Blumenfeld
- Mayor
- Carmine Caridi
- Frankie C.
- Margaret Cho
- Rental Car Agent
- Peter Cohen
- Peach Protestor #3
- Stephen Colbert
- TV Newsman
- Mike Connors
- Joe Mannix
- Paul Dooley
- Warden
- Murphy Dunne
- Psychiatrist
- Robert Englund
- Jack Sampson
- Charles Esten
- Conner Fulton
- Pat Finn
- Robber #2
- Janeane Garofalo
- Patty
- Melissa Green
- Young Miranda
- Archie Hahn
- Youth Leader
- Larry Hankin
- Blind Man
- Sebastian Hitzig
- Sarah's Cameraman
- Kristen Johnston
- Miranda
- Richard Kind
- Real Estate Agent
- Bill Kirchenbauer
- Jimmy's Father
- Ed Lauter
- Gun Expert
- Jay Leggett
- Prison Guard
- Michael Lerner
- Uncle Lou
- Joe Liss
- Savant
- Virginia Madsen
- Prison Lawyer
- Tim Meadows
- Cashier
- Adam Miller
- Young Jimmy
- Joel Murray
- Robber #1
- Lou Myers
- Blue Smoke Jones
- Mike Myers
- 'Eye' Witness
- Vladimir Nemirovsky
- Film Teacher
- David Pasquesi
- Jimmy
- Dominique Pinassi
- Phil's Receptionist
- Mary Kay Place
- Mrs. McClintock
- Harvey Poole
- Peach Protestor #1
- Susan Poole
- Peach Protestor #2
- Laura Rogers
- C Store Customer
- Wayne Rogers
- Gun Schnook
- Mitch Rouse
- Virus
- Robin Ruzan
- 'Eye' Witness #2
- Cynthia Szigeti
- Jimmy's Mother
- Olga Tannen
- Usherette #1
- Scott Thompson
- Mechanic
- Alanna Ubach
- Sarah
- Sophie Ward
- Claire Howard
- Fred Willard
- Mr. McClintock
- Richard Zavaglia
- Phil Phillips
- Holly Beavon
- Receptionist's Voice
- Joseph Dunn
- Theater manager
- Ryan Stiles
- Harold
- Ben Stiller
- Peach Expert
