- James Stewart
- Grant McLaine
- Audie Murphy
- Lee McLaine 'The Utica Kid'
- Dan Duryea
- Whitey Harbin
- Dianne Foster
- Charlotte 'Charlie' Drew
- Elaine Stewart
- Verna Kimball
- Brandon De Wilde
- Joey Adams
- Jay C. Flippen
- Ben Kimball
- Herbert Anderson
- Will Renner
- Robert J. Wilke
- Concho
- Hugh Beaumont
- Jeff Kurth
- Jack Elam
- Shotgun
- Tommy Cook
- Howdy Sladen
- Paul Fix
- Mr. Feeney
- Olive Carey
- Miss Vittles
- James Flavin
- Tim Riley
- Donald Curtis
- Jubilee
- Ellen Corby
- Mrs. Feeney
- John Daheim
- Latigo
- Kenny Williams
- O'Brien
- Frank Chase
- Trinidad
- Harold Goodwin
- Pick Gannon
- Harold 'Tommy' Hart
- Shannon
- Jack Williams
- Dusty
- Boyd Stockman
- Torgenson
- Henry Wills
- Pache
- Chuck Roberson
- Roan
- Willard W. Willingham
- Click
- Polly Burson
- Rosa
- Patsy Novak
- Linda
- Ted Mapes
- Leary
- Emile Avery
- Train Passenger
- Jerry Brown
- Train Passenger
- Clem Fuller
- Conductor
- Edwin C. Johnson
- Telegraph Operator Near Beginning
- William 'Bill' Phillips
- Blacksmith / Livery Stable Owner (uncredited)
- Ben Welden
- Pete
