- Will Branner
- Max Jägerman / Ensemble
- Mariah Rose Faith
- Stephanie Lauter / Caitlyn (as Mariah Rose Faith Casillas)
- Bryce Charles
- Detective Shapiro / Brenda / Ensemble
- Corey Dorris
- Mayor Solomon Lauter / Jason Jepson / Pokotho / Cop
- Angela Giarratana
- Grace Chasity / Drama Student
- Lauren Lopez
- Ruth Fleming / Donna Daggit / Emma Perkins / Bliklotep / Brooke
- Jon Matteson
- Richie Lipschitz / Boy Jerry / Trevor / Paul Matthews / Wiggog Y'Wrath / Student
- Curt Mega
- Officer Bailey / Mark Chasity / Kyle Clauger / T'noy Karaxis / News Announcer
- Joey Richter
- Peter Spankoffski / Dan Reynolds / Drama Student
- Kim Whalen
- Miss Mulberry / Karen Chasity / Reese / Miss Tessburger / Stacy / Nibblenephim
- Davis Weaver
- Cop / Reporter / Student (as Davis Hamilton)
- Virginia Vass
- Reporter / Student
- Jae Hughes
- Ziggy
- James Tolbert
- Charles
- Dylan Saunders
- Gerald Monroe
- Jeff Blim
- The Man in a Hurry / Principal
