- Jesse Ridgway
- Â Isaac Kalder 25 episodes, 2017-2018
- Lorenz Abraham
- Â Arachnid 23 episodes, 2017-2018
- Jeffrey Ridgway
- Â Joseph Kalder 22 episodes, 2017-2018
- Theresa Ridgway
- Â Mary II 16 episodes, 2017-2018
- Jeffrey Ridgway Jr.
- Â Michael 16 episodes, 2017-2018
- Jeffery Saxton Jr.
- Â Gingy 15 episodes, 2017-2018
- Kandis Orth
- Â Rebekah 14 episodes, 2017-2018
- Nick Caprio
- Â The Overlord / ... 14 episodes, 2017-2018
- Jay Castillo
- Â Malachi 13 episodes, 2017-2018
- Domenic Maisto
- Â Adam 13 episodes, 2017-2018
- Carina Cafiso
- Â Leah 13 episodes, 2017-2018
- Jackie Mixner
- Â Martha 12 episodes, 2018
- John Hagerty
- Â John 12 episodes, 2017-2018
- Melissa Stahlberger
- Â Sarah Cunningham 11 episodes, 2017-2018
- George Stahlberger
- Â Solomon 11 episodes, 2017-2018
- Chris Ridgway
- Â Archie 10 episodes, 2017-2018
- Jospeh Bumpus
- Â Noah 8 episodes, 2017-2018
- Jason Davis
- Â Jesus 8 episodes, 2018
- Josh Messick
- Â Longbags 7 episodes, 2017-2018
- Molly Sherman
- Â Eve Kalder 7 episodes, 2018
- Paul Marks
- Â Elijah 6 episodes, 2018
- Billy Thoden
- Â Tommy 6 episodes, 2018
- Paige White
- Â Samantha 6 episodes, 2017-2018
- Angela Golca
- Â Mary 6 episodes, 2017-2018
- Daniel Keem
- Â Daniel M. Keem 5 episodes, 2017-2018
- Austin Smith
- Â Judas 5 episodes, 2017-2018
- Buzz Simkins
- Â Captain Philips 5 episodes, 2018
- Connie Camerota
- Â Debbie 5 episodes, 2017-2018
- Lisa White
- Â Ruth 5 episodes, 2018
- Tyler St. Clair
- Â Jacob 5 episodes, 2018
- Margaret Lenard
- Â Elizabeth 4 episodes, 2018
- Joe Fleming
- Â Leah's Dad 4 episodes, 2018
- Tom Abraham
- Â Aaron Andrews 3 episodes, 2018
- Justin Hagerty
- Â Young Isaac 3 episodes, 2018
- Gail Donnelly
- Â Delilah 3 episodes, 2017-2018
- Tom McMahon
- Â Peter 3 episodes, 2018
- Christian Golca
- Â Paul 3 episodes, 2018
- Gigi Golca
- Â Hannah 3 episodes, 2018
- Maci Orth
- Â Rebekah's Sister 2 episodes, 2018
- Tommy Orth
- Â Rebekah's Brother 2 episodes, 2018
- Anita McCann
- Â Bot #1 1 episode, 2018
- Nancy McCann
- Â Bot #2 1 episode, 2018
- Tyler Atkinson
- Â Cop #1 1 episode, 2018
- Michael Manfre
- Â Cop #2 1 episode, 2018
- Shane Orth
- Â Cop #3 1 episode, 2018
- Nick Rugenus
- Â Solomon Brother #1 1 episode, 2018
- Ryan Rugenus
- Â Solomon Brother #2 1 episode, 2018
- Taylor Mason
- Â Solomon Brother #3 1 episode, 2018
- Miguel Mendez
- Â Solomon Brother #4 1 episode, 2018
- Jonny Pacheco
- Â Solomon Brother #5 1 episode, 2018
- Moamen Mohamed
- Â Solomon Brother #6 1 episode, 2018
- Javier Esteban Pozar
- Â Solomon Brother #7 1 episode, 2018
- Juliette Reilly
- Â Jogger 2 episodes, 2018
