- John Schmiederer
- James Righteous
- Brendan Nagle
- Parker
- Cecelia Gray
- Lela
- Jennie Pines
- Valerie Righteous
- Joseph Slater
- Butcher
- Tim Hatch
- Mr. Point
- Kyle Stahr
- Jake Righteous
- Mark Dufrense
- James' Father
- Jamel King
- Goon #1
- Rafeal Rivera
- Goon #2
- Sal Fusco
- Randy
- John Mac Schnurr
- Boy Toy
- Kyrsten St. Pierre
- Sarah
- Ed Rogers
- Larry
- Ed Stahr
- Detective #1
- Zachary Balog
- Detective #2
- Jenna Dott
- Butcher's Wife
- John Buckley
- Butcher's Son
- Kirin Payne
- Butcher's Daughter
- Jeff Burns
- Liquor Store Owner
- Michael P. DiPaolo
- Gun Store Owner
- S. Patrick Gabriels
- Nice Guy at Bar
- Megan Miller
- Bartender
- Jon Sorrentino
- Victim in Garage
- Jason Eveleth
- Customer at Liquor Store
- Nikki Johnson
- Butcher's Girl
- Taylor Burke
- Butcher's Girl
- Nikki Johnson
- Butcher's Girl
- Steve Murray
- Dr. Daniels
