- Larry Stanley
- Dean
- Greg Jake Gibbins
- James
- Rich Kordsmeier
- Eric
- Jason Rowe
- Mike
- Brianna Brill
- Misty
- Rose Epler
- Edie
- Bridgette Mishelle
- Jessie
- Michelle Nickleberry
- Donna
- Terry Vanderheyden
- Stephano Poser
- Lindsey Hertel
- April
- Richard Houghton
- Mr.Norris
- Janet Kirby
- Mrs. Norris
- Chase Turbiville
- Jake
- Robb Hudspeth
- Preacher
- Kimberly Ann Bowles
- Get Away Driver
- Angela Waits
- Pregnant Girlfriend
- April Tally
- Dean's Ex-Girlfriend
- Sara Manning
- Girl from the past
- Christine Kiefer
- Ex Girlfriend
- Madi Conelly
- Dean's Cousin
- Nicole Buss
- Park Bench Woman
- Rene Gonzales
- Cousin's Friend
- Floyd Miller
- Dean's Friend
- Noreen Moy
- Jogging Woman
- Lance Winters
- Church Goer #15
- Daniel Vigil
- Church Goer #16
- Joe Tebean
- Church Goer #8
- Trevor Spathias
- Brother's Friend
- Roger Smith
- Church Goer #3
- Natalie Smith
- Church Goer #13
- Lea Simpkins
- Church Goer #1
- Zach Rutland
- Church Goer #4
- Brandi Rutland
- Church Goer #5
- Melissa Rogers
- (voice)
- Stephen Knowles
- Church Goer #14
- Christine Houchin
- Church Goer #17
- Wade Hicks
- Church Goer #12
- Antonio Gonzales
- Church Goer #9
- Carolyn Gibson
- Church Goer #7
- Billy Foster
- Church Goer #6
- Afton Caiborne
- Church Goer #2
