- Kevin Sorbo
- Doc Boyd
- Tyler Mane
- Thurman Dial
- John Ratzenberger
- Dad Everett
- Louis Gossett Jr.
- Irving Tanner Jr.
- Gwynyth Walsh
- Classafay Vaudine
- Sam Sorbo
- Flora May Simms
- Paula Boudreau
- Juniper Sue Dial
- Braeden Sorbo
- Matt
- Faith Louissaint
- Angry Congregant
- James Quattrochi
- Bailiff
- Charles Andrew Payne
- Reverend Reese
- Gloria John
- Townswoman / Courtroom Attendee (voice)
- AnnaMarie Lea
- Therma Lou Jones
- Jonathan Hawley Purvis
- L.D. Heinz
- Hardee T. Lineham
- Mr. Grimm
- Shawna McGill-Legault
- Housewife
- Larry Bullied
- Captain Enrique Rodriguez
- Melissa Cambridge
- Angry Widow with Shotgun
- Maddi Jane
- Denise
- Orin McCusker
- Irving Tanner Sr.
- Nancy Boyd
- Widow
- Julie Brett
- Townswoman / Courtroom Attendee (voice)
- Cat Elliott
- Townswoman / Courtroom Attendee (voice)
- Donna-Lynne Larson
- Martha Jean Tyler
- Matt McKinney
- Mr. Wimple
- Anthony Fontana
- Townsman / Courtroom Attendee (voice)
- Jill Maria Robinson
- Wife of (John Ratzenberger) Dad Everett
- Wrama Willis
- Della May Irving
- Dave Brynlund
- Courtroom Attendee
- Nate Bockelman
- Townsman / Courtroom Attendee (voice)
- Brent Kuhn
- Judge J.J. Watson
- Leslie Hucul
- Widow
- Julio Mateo
- Oil Worker
- Johnny Walker
- Townsman
- Steven Muratori
- Rancher
- Mike McCarthy
- Rancher / Oil Worker
- Koen Aerts
- Young Dad Everett
- Lyndsey Alston
- Saloon Waitress
- Michael Aucoin
- Engineer
- Cara Azevedo
- Townsperson
- Marnie Madden
- Attendee
- Brad Pajot
- Courtroom Attendee
- Gordon Rix
- Juror / Town Doctor (uncredited)
