- June Squibb
- Gladys Sokolowski
- Jeff Hiller
- Graham Hargreaves
- Martin Sheen
- Dr. Austin Raybourne
- Liza Weil
- Sophie Mathers
- Stacy Keach
- Will Sokolowski
- Dennis Haysbert
- Marty Anderson
- Dot-Marie Jones
- Sharon Weymouth
- Esther Povitsky
- Sara Levine
- Jon Lovitz
- Mayor of Cleveland
- Loretta Devine
- Joy Morris
- Santino Fontana
- Gary Lucarelli
- Vanessa Burghardt
- Hannah Mathers
- Rob Mayes
- Frank
- Mark L. Walberg
- Host Tom L. Hanks
- Yvette Yates Redick
- Maria Toddy
- Rory O'Malley
- Hugh Robinson
- Bryant Carroll
- Butcher
- Heidi Lewandowski
- Bonnie
- Bryan Coffee
- Store Manager
- Stephon Fuller
- Sheldon White
- Denise Dal Vera
- Constipated Appraiser
- Rich Williams
- Lou
- Christopher Mele
- Film and tv appraiser
- Joette Waters
- Stacey
- Greg Violand
- Male Volunteer
- David Towne
- Josh
- Benjamin Steinhauser
- Charlie Toddy
- Michelle Gillette
- Rascal Rider
- Logan Soland
- Bobby
- Lissy Gulick
- Wanita
- Samuel Roter
- Carlton Hanna
- Chris Bohan
- Laverne
- Agnes Herrmann
- Mrs. Xanthopolou
- Allen R. Middleton
- Realtor
- Scott Shirai
- Mr. Jin
- Jeffrey L. Holmes
- Background
- Ro M. Allen
- Rosemary Anderson
- David Alligood
- Roadshow Attendee
- Anya Arciaga
- Parade Attendee
- Luke Bly
- College Student
- Suzie Coker
- Party Guest
- Dave Edmonds
- Party Guest
- Mykaela Euton
- College Student
- David Goebel
- Restaurant Patron
- Beverly Kristy
- Restaurant Patron
- Robert Maple
- Church Congregation
- Zachary Marshall
- College Student
- Shawn Michelle
- Roadshow Attendee
- Sue Danna Myer
- Amish Maid
- Roger Petan
- Sweater guy at Roadshow
- Hailey Reinke
- Solider's Wife
- Derwin Rowser
- Mayor's Chief of Staff
- Brian Sokol
- Parade Attendee
- Cindi Verbelun
- Playhouse Square Redcoat / Auction Attendee (uncredited)
- Paul Worley
- Roadshow Attendee
- Stan Zbarasheuski
- Amish Gardener
