- Jay Dobyns
- Bob Norris
- Paul Ferm
- Santa Claus
- Andrew Ferrick
- Brian's Thug #2
- Darin Foltz
- Dave
- Richard Goteri
- Captain Gil Farabee
- Mark Hensel
- Bar Brawler
- Samantha Hoepfl
- Heather Duffin
- Emily Kessler
- Sean's Girlfriend
- Annette Lawless
- Jeremy's mother
- Angelina Leigh
- Krampus's pet
- A.J. Leslie
- Jeremy Duffin
- John Marazza
- Brian's Thug
- Mike Merrell
- Bar Brawler #2
- Michael Mili
- Bartender Harry
- Bill Oberst Jr.
- Brian Hatt
- Brian Patterson
- Jeremy's Father
- Jared Sidun
- Young Jeremy Duffin
- Jeremy Sidun
- John Walker
- Matthew Siman
- Narrator
- Erica Soto
- Rebecca Duffin
- Heather Travis
- Bartender
- Benny Weaver
- Sean Roberts
- Brad Weaver
- Boy Playing
