- Amy Schumer
- Lainy Newton
- Will Forte
- Josh Lewis
- Jillian Bell
- Kate
- Brianne Howey
- Megan Taylor
- Lizze Broadway
- Shirley
- Urzila Carlson
- Fallon
- Chris Geere
- Steve
- Damon Wayans Jr.
- Dave
- Alex Moffat
- Rawn
- Joel David Moore
- Mark
- Jackie Sandler
- Yoga Class Teacher
- Molly Sims
- Prenatal Workshop Teacher
- Chris Titone
- Barista
- Duke McCloud
- Connor
- Robbie Crandall
- Liam
- Max Malas
- Brett
- Kennedy Rae Thompson
- Amber
- Kylie Kuioka
- Emily
- Alice Sophie Malyukova
- Julia
- Hayley Griffith
- Moira
- Sunny Sandler
- Daisy
- Laura Benanti
- Daisy's Mom
- Jayne Sowers
- Young Lainy Newton (7 years old)
- Julianna Layne
- Young Kate (7 years old)
- Austin Ku
- Proposal Restaurant Waiter
- Allison Strong
- Dumbo Waitress
- Crystal Finn
- Maternity Store Sales Woman
- Connie Shi
- San Pellegrino
- Dave Attell
- Shirley's Father
- Gordon Schumer
- Mazel Wheelchair Guy
- Jackie Fabulous
- Congratulating Woman
- Sarah Osman
- Thumbs Up Person
- James Ciccone
- Big Smile Person
- Denzel Rodriquez
- Bob The Grocer
- Cailen Fu
- May (Pregnant Yoga Class Student)
- Francis Benhamou
- Jane (Pregnant Yoga Class Student)
- Alestair Shu
- Tim
- Sarah Cooper
- Trish
- Margaret Rose Champagne
- Bridget
- Anna Venizelos
- Pregnant Contortionist
- Dave Ben Jaffe
- Threesome Bandleader
- Antoine Drye
- Threesome Musician
- Calvin Johnson
- Threesome Musician
- Keith Robinson
- Subway Rider With Bad Attitude
- Maura Gaynor
- Butterfly Guide
- Anisha Nagarajan
- Mehta Family Mom
- Aalok Mehta
- Mehta Family Dad
- Aaliya Mehta
- Mehta Family Kid #1
- Arin Mehta
- Mehta Family Kid #2
- Kat Gonzalez
- Pre-Natal Workshop Lady
- Nickellia Whitaker
- Pre-Natal Workshop Lady
- Alana Randall
- Pre-Natal Workshop Lady
- Amanda Boekelheide
- Pre-Natal Workshop Lady
- Esther Cunningham
- Pre-Natal Workshop Lady
- Ryan J. Haddad
- Male Teacher
- Tyler Spindel
- Voice of Andy
- Danielle Flora
- Dancer
- C.J. Tyson
- Dancer #1
- Derek Piquette
- Dancer #2
- Mishay Petronelli
- Dancer #3
- Autavia Bailey
- Dancer #4
- Kevin Alexis Rivera
- Breakdancer
- Madonna Akhtar
- Student
- Elaine Apruzzese
- Guest at a Gender Reveal Party
- Matt Barbiere
- Restaurant Patron
- Brandon Bright
- Middle School Student
- Craig Castaldo
- Radio Man
- Daniel Cioffoletti
- Park Goer
- Ethan Clark
- Macy's Customer (Kid)
- Lucas Colterelli
- Student
- Ashanti Cox
- Background
- Vayda Cronin
- Background Student Playground
- Will Fitz
- Party Guest
- Cory Fratus
- Restaraunt Patron
- Dennis Jay Funny
- Ice Skater
- David Goff
- Male Teacher
- Mellisa Goodwin
- Old Hollywood Actress
- Milana Grace
- Student
- Daniel Hirsh
- Karaoke Guy
- Tom Johnson
- Ice skater
- Tyler Johnson
- Restaurant Patron
- Matthew Karpov
- Student
- Marie Laine
- Older Woman on Bike
- Hannah Lambie
- Middle School Student
- Boris London
- School Student
- Jasmine Major
- Background
- Mikella Matthias
- Flower Shopper
- Christine McBurney
- Angry New Yorker
- Kendra Middleton
- Restaurant Patron
- Nichia Morales
- Restaurant Patron
- Damian Muziani
- Angry New Yorker
- Pretzky
- (uncredited)
- Michelle Santiago
- Pedestrian
- Leonel Severino
- Leo Ramen
- Shefik
- Subway Rider / Park Goer (uncredited)
- Andre Toure
- Restaurant Patron
- La'Charles Trask
- Macy Employee
- Autumn Skye Waltrip
- Student
- Odain Watson
- Restaurant Patron
- Ryan Jacob Wazne
- Student
- Mahkah Wright
- Ms. Sherrie student
- Tuari Wright
- School student
