- Branscombe Richmond
- Professor M
- Pam Renall
- Mrs. Clare
- Mike Wolfe
- Mr. Gates
- Anthony Laurita
- Zane
- Heath C. Heine
- Pastor Gates
- Bobby Lee Black
- Farmer 1
- Shale Le Page
- Quinto
- Joe Rizzo
- Farmer Joe
- Cuan Snyman
- Cameron
- Eddie Schumacher
- Principal
- Robert Abbott
- George
- Karis Peterson
- Alexa
- Mira Barlament
- Background performer
- Heather Strickland
- Gretchen
- Joe Bocian
- Father Fontoni
- Patrick Carey
- Farmer 2
- John Dembiczak
- City worker
- Jon Cotton
- Military Officer
- William Trujillo
- Farmer Earle
- Caiden Almeyda
- Young Pastor Gates / Skeleton
- Drew Sanford
- Janitor / Farmer Drew
- Michelle Mras
- News Anchor
- Michael Mras
- Witch
- Shawn Heitman
- Bio Man 1
- Kristi Davis
- Sheriff
- Jane Barlament
- Background performer
- Dave Bralish
- Farmer Dave
- Gabriella Bean
- Girl 2
- Kara Castro
- Sebastian
- Kevin M. Archuleta
- Young Earl / Skeleton
- Branden Kieft
- Witch
- Kate Kaemmerling
- Girl 1
- Cooper Hyde
- Background performer
- Matthew Archuleta
- Background performer
- Noel Archuleta
- Background performer
- Illa Belle Parkin
- Background performer
- Grady N Bowman
- Background performer
- Ryan Wigginton
- Red
- Cailyn Hyde
- Background performer
- Cliff Cage
- Radio Voice
- Lauren Bormanis
- Background performer
