- Ben Stiller
- Rabbi Jake Schram
- Edward Norton
- Father Brian Finn
- Jenna Elfman
- Anna Riley
- Anne Bancroft
- Ruth Schram
- Eli Wallach
- Rabbi Ben Lewis
- Ron Rifkin
- Larry Friedman
- Milos Forman
- Father Havel
- Holland Taylor
- Bonnie Rose
- Lisa Edelstein
- Ali Decker
- Rena Sofer
- Rachel Rose
- Ken Leung
- Don
- Brian George
- Paulie Chopra
- Catherine Lloyd Burns
- Debbie
- Susie Essman
- Ellen Friedman
- Stuart Blumberg
- Len
- Samuel Goldberg
- Teenage Jake Schram
- Michael Charles Roman
- Teenage Brian Finn
- Blythe Auffarth
- Teenage Anna Riley
- Jonathan Randell Silver
- Alan Klein
- Brian Anthony Wilson
- T-Bone
- Juan Piedrahita
- Omar
- Kelly Deadmon
- Woman in Bar
- Raphael M.A. Frieder
- Cantor
- Bodhi Elfman
- Howard the Casanova
- Chris Gardner
- Basketball Kid #1
- Santi Formosa
- Basketball Kid #2
- Francine Beers
- Greta Nussbaum
- Rena Blumberg
- Chaya
- Ellen Hauptman
- Roz Lentz
- Liz Larsen
- Leslie
- Matt Winston
- Matt
- Nelson Avidon
- Joel
- David Wain
- Steve Posner
- Donna Hanover
- Confessional Woman #1
- Wai Ching Ho
- Confessional Woman #2
- Howard Greller
- Doctor
- Brenda Denmark
- Nurse
- Marilyn Cooper
- 'Don't Walk' Lady
- Hawk Koch
- Rabbinical Professor
- Craig Castaldo
- Radio Man
- Keith Perry
- Old Man Hit with the Censor
- John Arocho
- Bully
- Derrick Eason
- Co-Worker
- Ray Carlson
- Monsignor
- Barbara Haas
- Mother in Synagogue Reception Room
- Sunny Keyser
- Mother
- Lorna Lable
- Mother
- Paula Raflo
- Mother
- Hillary Brook Canter
- Daughter
- Dana Lubotsky
- Daughter
- Alexandra Rella
- Daughter
- Eugene S. Katz
- Mohel
- Tony Rossi
- Hot Dog Vendor
- John P. Duffell
- Father Duffell
- Keith Williams
- AIDS Patient
- Dagmara Dominczyk
- Claire
- Kryss Anderson
- Craig
- Sophia Alexis
- Party Guest
- Tony Devon
- Jewish Neighbor
- Giovanni Capitello
- Bartender at cocktail party
- Bronwen Carson
- Sexy Secretary
- Robin Clark
- Singer In Gospel Choir
- Andre Da Silva
- Guitar player
- John Gigante
- UPS Delivery Guy
- Dan Griffin
- Various
- Jeff Millstein
- Synagogue member / movie patron (scenes deleted)
- Tom Modern
- Party Guest
- Joseph Oliveira
- Night Club Patron
- Laura Summer
- (voice)
- Amy Wilson
- Ruth
- Frank Floyd
- Choir Member
- Curt Hayward
- Transvestite Hooker
- Jessica Heilig Montanez Prince
- Synagogue Member
- Paul Hogan
- Karaoke Singer Sean
- Mike Knox
- Flier
- Martin Pfefferkorn
- Homeless Man
- Shabazz Ray
- Self
- Robert F. Saunders
- Man in Front Row
- Bernard J. Tarver
- Movie Theater Patron
- Cliff Townsend
- Gospel Choir Member
