- Gina Holden
- Julia Fogg
- Lochlyn Munro
- Captain Cyrus Harding
- Pruitt Taylor Vince
- Gideon Spilett
- Susie Abromeit
- Abby Fogg
- Mark Sheppard
- Young Captain Nemo
- JD Evermore
- Bonaventure Pencroft
- Edrick Browne
- Neb Nugent
- Caleb Michaelson
- Herbert Brown
- William Morgan Sheppard
- Captain Nemo
- Vincent C. Abadio
- Civil War Soldier
- Jonathan Algood
- Nautilus Crew / Creature
- Lucas Bernard
- Civil War Soldier
- Grayling Bethancourt Jr.
- Nautilus Crew / Creature
- Raymond Blanchard
- Nautilus Crew / Creature
- Marc Bowman
- Civil War Soldier
- Michael Boyd
- Nautilus Crew / Creature
- Keith Bradford
- Civil War Soldier
- James M. Cannon
- Civil War Soldier
- William Diaz
- Civil War Soldier
- Shalayne Diggs
- Pirate Girl
- Ben Flickinger
- Civil War Soldier
- David Flickinger
- Civil War Soldier
- Kenneth Greene
- Civil War Soldier
- Luke Hawx
- Pirate
- Andre Jacob
- Civil War Soldier
- Randy Jarreau
- Civil War Soldier
- Gerrit King
- Civil War Soldier
- Chip Landry
- Civil War Soldier
- Joshua Lerch
- Civil War Soldier
- Peter J. Manning
- Civil War Soldier
- Sean Manning
- Civil War Soldier
- William Manning
- Civil War Soldier
- Michael Matherne
- Civil War Soldier
- William Matherne
- Civil War Soldier
- Ryan Moll Jr.
- Nautilus Crew / Creature
- Chris Montiville
- Nautilus Crew / Creature
- Carlos Rodriguez
- Nautilus Crew / Creature
- Robert Roscoe
- Civil War Soldier
- Andrew Sensenig
- Nautilus Crew / Creature
- Tony Senzamici
- Private Lynch
- Timothy Sharrock
- Civil War Soldier
- John Eric Sledge
- Civil War Soldier
- Keith J. Strohpaul
- Civil War Soldier
- S. West Summers Jr.
- Civil War Soldier
- Jacob Tolano
- Confederate Soldier #2
- Jacob Treadway
- Civil War Soldier
- Lawrence Turner
- Tom Ayrton
- Eric VanArsdale
- Pirate
- John Wagley
- Civil War Soldier
- John Wilson
- Nautilus Crew / Creature (as John T. Wilson)
- Adam C. Wisher
- Civil War Soldier
