- Patrick Dempsey
- Ellsworth 'Sonny' Wisecarver
- Talia Balsam
- Judy
- Beverly D'Angelo
- Francine
- Michael Constantine
- Mr. Wisecarver - Sonny's Father
- Betty Jinnette
- Mrs. Wisecarver - Sonny's Mother
- Kathleen Freeman
- Mrs. Marver - The Landlady
- Peter Hobbs
- The Judge
- Tony Longo
- Carlo - Judy's Husband
- Douglas Rowe
- Uncle Clete
- Ernie Lively
- Chief Kelsey - 'Papa Bear'
- Kim Myers
- Wendy - The Usherette
- Brian McNamara
- George
- Dana Short
- Alberta
- Joshua Cadman
- Tony
- Nan Woods
- Madeline
- Tom Bresnahan
- Gary
- Gillian Grant
- Karen
- Lisanne Falk
- Jamie
- Barbara Wint
- School Nurse
- Burr Middleton
- FBI Agent Harrow
- Jared Chandler
- Western Union Messenger
- Edith Fellows
- Dorothy - Judy's Mother
- Tom Tarpey
- Reporter #1 in Front Yard
- Crane Jackson
- Reporter #2 in Front Yard
- Neil Elliot
- Arresting Cop
- Mae Williams
- Angry Neighbor #1
- Janet Rotblatt
- Angry Neighbor #2
- Harvey J. Goldenberg
- Yuma Marriage License Clerk
- Tom Maier
- Yuma Judge
- Putter Smith
- Minister
- Lenore Woodward
- Justice of the Peace
- Lee Garlington
- Schlitz' Waitress
- Charles C. Stevenson Jr.
- Western Union Telegraph Clerk
- Carl D. Parker
- Ticket Agent
- Wayne Grace
- Bus Driver
- Jeffrey Alan Chandler
- Hotel Clerk
- Robert Gould
- Det. Glore
- Jordan Myers
- Desk Sergeant
- Rick Salassi
- News Photographer #1
- Walter G. Zeri
- Sonny's Cellmate
- Nitche Vo Miller
- Judy's Cellmate #1
- Laura Bastianelli
- Judy's Cellmate #2
- Thomas Ryan
- News Photographer #2
- Ted Noose
- Denver Reporter #1
- Charlie Holliday
- Denver Reporter #2
- Valerie Reynolds
- Policewoman
- Rocky Giordani
- Tough Inmate
- Darwyn Swalve
- Huge Inmate
- W.T. Zacha
- Jail Guard
- Kitty Swink
- Betty - Sponge Bath Nurse
- Sarah Partridge
- Winking Nurse
- Steve Whittaker
- Three-Fingered Surgeon
- Thomas Albert Clay
- Five-Fingered Surgeon
- Tony Monaco
- L.A. District Attorney
- Terry Camilleri
- Mr. Browning - Judy's Lawyer
- Mike Darrell
- Bailiff
- David Schermerhorn
- Courtroom Heckler #1
- John Zarchen
- Courtroom Heckler #2
- Cletus Young
- Sonny's Guard
- Guy Christopher
- L.A. Reporter #1
- Paul Keith
- L.A. Reporter #2
- Neal Jano
- L.A. Reporter #3
- Bert Conway
- Newspaper Editor
- Joycee Katz
- Rosie the Riveter
- Ana Helena Berenguer
- Maria - The Tuna Lady
- Jay Varela
- Maria's Husband - The Tuna Foreman
- Michael Bandoni
- Rooming House Boarder
- Sheila Rogers
- Mrs. Kelsey - 'Mama Bear'
- Heath Jones
- Paradise Reporter
- S.A. Griffin
- Cpl. Howard Glatt USMC
- Tom Patten
- Marine with 'Stars and Stripes'
- Ellsworth 'Sonny' Wisecarver
- Mailman
- Randy Peters
- Serviceman
- Marilyn Cohen
- Yenta
- Niles Brewster
- High School Principal
- Bess Meyer
- Slapping Teenage Girl
- Max Perlich
- Slapping Teenage Boy
- Andrew Roperto
- Switchblade Kid at Youth Facility
- Thomas W. Ashworth
- Man on Train Who Spots Sonny
- Rocky Parker
- Woman on Train
- Carl Reiner
- Alan Brady - Newsreel Narrator
- Reynaldo Silva
- Inmate
- Dave Thomas
- Bob Hope
