- Fredric March
- Jonathan Wooley / Nathaniel Wooley / Samuel Wooley / Wallace Wooley
- Veronica Lake
- Jennifer
- Robert Benchley
- Dr. Dudley White
- Susan Hayward
- Estelle Masterson
- Cecil Kellaway
- Daniel
- Elizabeth Patterson
- Margaret
- Eily Malyon
- Tabitha Wooley
- Robert Warwick
- J.B. Masterson
- Robert Greig
- Town Crier
- Viola Moore
- Martha
- Mary Field
- Nancy Wooley
- Nora Cecil
- Harriet Wooley
- Emory Parnell
- Allen - Hotel Owner
- Helen St. Rayner
- Singer at Wedding
- Aldrich Bowker
- Justice of the Peace
- Emma Dunn
- Wife of Justice of the Peace
- John Alban
- Wedding Guest
- Beverly Andre
- Girl at Country Club
- Georgia Backus
- Older Woman
- Charles Bates
- Wooley's Son
- Brooks Benedict
- Country Club Extra
- Billy Bevan
- Puritan Vendor
- Edward Biby
- Spectator at Fire
- Marie Blake
- Purity Sykes
- Billy Bletcher
- Wedding Photographer
- Monte Blue
- Pilgrim Hotel Doorman
- Wade Boteler
- Policeman Arresting Daniel
- Al Bridge
- Second Prison Guard
- Ann Carter
- Jennifer Wooley - Wooley's Daughter
- Eddy Chandler
- Motorcycle Cop
- Chester Conklin
- Party Bartender
- Georgie Cooper
- Wedding Guest
- Gino Corrado
- Onlooker in Crowd
- Gordon De Main
- Man with Masterson on Radio
- Jack Deery
- Country Club Guest
- Ralph Dunn
- First Prison Guard
- Frank Elliott
- Magistrate
- Franklyn Farnum
- Country Club Guest
- Bess Flowers
- Matron of Honor
- Jack Gardner
- Radio Voice
- Joe Gilbert
- Wedding Guest
- Florence Gill
- Woman Playing Chess
- George Guhl
- Fred - Policeman
- William Haade
- Policeman at Ambulance
- Reed Hadley
- Young Man
- Oscar 'Dutch' Hendrian
- Tom - Bartender
- Robert Homans
- Fire Chief
- Esther Howard
- Wedding Guest
- Arthur Stuart Hull
- Wedding Guest
- Donivee Lee
- Bridesmaid
- Peter Leeds
- Ambulance Attendant
- Jack Luden
- Ambulance Driver
- Renny McEvoy
- Bellboy
- David McKim
- Newsboy
- James Millican
- Wedding Guest
- Frank Mills
- Joe - Cab Driver
- Charles R. Moore
- Rufus - Samuel's Servant
- Edmund Mortimer
- Wedding Guest
- Ralph Peters
- Second Prisoner
- Gerald Pierce
- Newsboy
- Mickey Rentschler
- Boy at Country Club
- Cyril Ring
- Country Club Extra
- Ronald R. Rondell
- Wedding Guest
- Loretta Russell
- Country Club Guest
- Kathryn Sheldon
- Elderly Wife
- Ernest Shields
- Waiter
- Lee Shumway
- Fireman
- Bert Stevens
- Country Club Guest
- Amzie Strickland
- Girl at Country Club
- Harry Tyler
- First Prisoner
- Dan White
- Fireman
