- Stephen Atherholt
- Henry Wadsworth Longfellow
- Rachel Day Hughes
- Fanny Longfellow
- Jonathan Blair
- Charley Longfellow
- Zach Meeker
- Ernest Longfellow
- Ava Munn
- Alice Mary Longfellow
- Eloise McComas
- Edith Longfellow
- Lucy Amos
- Anne Allegra Longfellow
- Chris Wert
- Thomas Appleton
- Chris Faith
- Reverend
- Johnny Russell
- Adjutant General
- Syvia Glory
- Mary
- Shane Litchfield
- Elliot Gleason
- Daniel Stargel
- Senator Charles Sumner
- Carl Anderson
- Josiah Wilson
- Rodney Coe
- Banquet Host
- Jeff Bender
- Commanding Officer
- Wes Wise
- Richard
- Seth G. Antes
- Dr. Babayev
- Bill Shiplet
- Rebel Sharpshooter
- Robert Chirico
- Rebel Soldier #2
- Jacob Cummings
- Military Messenger
- Jay Dombach
- Artist
- Michael Neiderer
- Colonel #1
- Leah Rooney
- Older Anne Allegro
- Mingo Arvizu
- Mary's Father
- Joy Schaeffer
- Mary's Mother
- Kolby Colmary
- Mary's Brother
- Scott Ticen
- Recruiter
- Kerry Williard
- Recruiter #2
- Bryson Buffington
- Colonel #2
- Michael Hudson
- Unkempt Soldier
- Nicholas Shane Keeton
- Soldier 1
- Isaac Witt
- Soldier 2
- Tobias Kaj
- Soldier 3
- Caleb Heckman
- Soldier 4 (Banjo)
- Joshua Enck
- Bell Ringer Father
- Landon Enck
- Bell Ringer Son
- Daniel Lehning
- Church Elder
- Hannah Long
- Ernest's Wife
- Rachel Stargel
- Older Alice Mary
- Lauren McComas
- Older Edith
- Caleb Hughes
- Older Edith's Husband
- Paul Marini
- Banquet Server #1
- Nick Haney
- Banquet Server #2
- Ray Hilton
- Chef Ranhofer
- Gail Edgell
- Organist
- Jackie Moeller
- Finale Organist
- Bradley Mattson
- Choir Member
- Jennifer Mattson
- Choir Member
- Kathy Crusi
- Choir Member
- Josh Crusi
- Choir Member
- Kevin Lynch
- Choir Member
- Jeremiah Miller
- Choir Member
- Anna Gail Fenn
- Choir Member
- Sue Zuke
- Choir Member
- Steve Palmer
- Choir Member
- Mari Morgan
- Choir Member
- Douglas Wimer
- Choir Member
- Chad Marriott
- Choir Member
- Jacob L.T Bates
- Civilian on Porch
- Jared Frederick
- Massachusetts Infantryman
- Jeremiah Hornbaker
- Man at train station
- Morrissa Mae Scott
- Woman at the parade
