- Joe Boyd
- Ezekiel Yoder
- Matt Donnelly
- Bob 'Dirty' Rivers
- Mike Betette
- Dean Livy
- Megan Soule
- Carol Marshall
- Tara Rice
- Jaylor Marshall
- Jen Johnson
- Keri Kerrington
- Christopher Day
- William Argo
- Holly Walker
- Jill Fields
- Bobby Rodgers
- Mayor Stetson
- Sean Michael Murphy
- Rev. Thomas Masterson
- Nick Ghizas
- Josh Rivers
- Bekka Prewitt
- Rebecca Masterson
- Eddie Annal
- Mr. Ripley
- Russ Beckner
- Rusty
- Ashley E. Boehm
- Waitress
- Aidan Boyd
- Josiah Yoder
- Debbie Boyd
- Scooter Girl Trainee #2
- Eli Boyd
- Luke Yoder
- John Bromels
- Fire Guy
- Anthony W. Carter
- Poker Dealer
- Randy Cash
- Scooter Jones
- Quinn Cifani
- Mary Yoder
- Cameron Comstock
- Poker Dealer
- Elliot Docherty
- Mark Yoder
- Gavin Docherty
- Matthew Yoder
- Scott Docherty
- Father Clive Hayden
- Joseph E. Elam
- Main Poker Dealer
- Rammi Esreb
- Poker Dealer
- William Jonathan Georges
- Geeky Friend #2
- Chris Heaton
- Rock Russell
- Tim Hilderbrand
- Country Dude
- Jon Eric Hoffman
- Poker Dealer
- Korey T. Kiepert
- Wild Willy Wilder
- Karen Krueger
- Doris Livy
- Dean McKenzie
- Dusty
- Annie Murphy
- Scooter Girl Trainee #3
- Peggy Murphy
- Mrs. Murphy
- Amanda Ohly
- Miriam Yoder
- Ashley Palmer
- Marla
- Zachary David Palmer
- Restaurant Patron
- Luke Pater
- Biker Guy
- Leah Ransohoff
- Geeky Friend #1
- Chip Redden
- Poker Dealer
- Kathryn Remesch-Sarnecki
- Older Lady Fighter #3
- Devra Rochelle
- Losing Poker Player
- Melissa Scalia
- Scooter Girl Trainee #1
- Jocelyn Sluka
- Older Lady Fighter #1
- Christopher Smyth
- Jedediah
- Daniel Smyth
- Congregant
- Isaac Stambaugh
- Deputy Hutchinson
- Gregg Swadener
- Congregant
- Mary Kay Swadener
- Congregant
- Mat Thornburg
- Scotty Argo
- Missy Whitis
- Organist
- Paula Zo
- Older Lady Fighter #2
