- David Gyasi
- Bass Reeves
- Ron Perlman
- Charlie Storm
- Frank Grillo
- Bob Dozier
- Manu Intiraymi
- Judge Parker
- Chris Mullinax
- Marshall Franks
- Ashley Atwood
- Jessie Winston
- Gianni Capaldi
- Tom Pinkerton
- Jaqueline Fleming
- Nellie
- Michael Aaron Milligan
- Jim Bruce
- Randy Wayne
- Irish Jack
- Marshall R. Teague
- Senator Smith
- Zahn McClarnon
- Sam Sixkiller
- Curtis Nichouls
- Pap
- David William Arnott
- President Grant
- John D. Hickman
- Attendant
- Robert Goon
- Jailer
- Amber Sweet
- Bell Starr
- Carlos Velazquez
- Ned
- Alexander Kane
- Frank James
- James Whitecloud
- Indian on Horse
- Rudy Youngblood
- Rufus Buck / John in Gallows
- Kevin McGirt
- Older Indian Outlaw
- Jake Mast
- Billy
- Monte Stone
- Jeff
- Jacob Outsen
- Soldier
- Nick Loren
- Captain George Reeves
- Jo Scrape
- Townswoman
- Jessica Baker
- Creek Lady Piano Player
- Sam Reed
- Harmonica Player
- Kenneth Lee Tolbert
- Banjo Player
- Karis Lamb
- Violin Player
- Kerrington Gilbert
- Harriett
- Ryan Francis
- Mail Carrier
- Gino Shvetz
- Muskogee Saloon Patron
- Vernon Davis
- Columbus
- Kat Elizabeth Arild
- Townswoman
- Natasha Armstrong
- Dancing Townswoman
- Donald Ray Arnold
- Guard
- Jorge Castro-Salinas
- Dozier's Guard
- John Collier
- Outlaw
- Carly Farish
- Prostitute
- Shawn Fitzwater
- Dozier's Guard
- Haley Flanagan
- Saloon Dancer
- James H Keating
- Dozier Guard
- Hassel Kromer
- U.S. Marshal / Outlaw / Gambler / Confederate Soldier (uncredited)
- Savannah Lathem
- Elizabeth
- Don Lay
- Confederate Colonel / Townsman (uncredited)
- David R. Mitchell
- Gallow Personal
- Patrick S. O'Brien
- Townsman
- Ginny Posey
- Townswoman
- Randy Razook
- Outlaw Gambler
- Jerrica Ricard
- Augusta
- Rebecca Sheehan
- Bob Dozier's Wife
- Leslie Sides
- Townswoman
- Daniel Stone
- Outlaw
- James Christopher Sutton
- Cowboy 4
- Emily Towles
- Seductress
- Joey Traywick
- Dozier Guard
- Valerie Turner
- Townswoman
- MWW Michael Wilkerson
- Gallows Man
- Rob Wolfe
- Clarence
- Kodai Yamaguchi
- Dozier's Guard
