- Don Ameche
- Lew Marsh
- Frances Dee
- Agnes Marsh
- Harry Carey
- Gramp
- Ann Rutherford
- Lenore Prentiss
- Cara Williams
- Gretchen Barry
- Richard Crane
- Russell 'Rusty' Marsh
- Harry Morgan
- Anton 'Tony' Cavrek
- Minor Watson
- Judge Colvin
- Dickie Moore
- Peter Orcutt
- June Preston
- Mrs. Prentiss daughter
- Richard Abbott
- Reverend Wood
- Jackie Averill
- Tod
- Walter Baldwin
- Jake Hibbs
- Joseph E. Bernard
- Clerk
- Lillian Bronson
- Mattie Dyer
- Marjorie Cooley
- Teacher
- Adeline De Walt Reynolds
- Mrs. Schneider
- John Dilson
- Charles Clayton
- Ned Dobson Jr.
- Jackie
- Robert Dudley
- Old Man Bowers
- Elvin Field
- Joe
- Reed Hadley
- Off-Screen Narrator
- Darla Hood
- Lenore Prentiss - Age 12
- Milton Kibbee
- Shep Wayne
- Pass Le Noir
- Dr. Hammond
- Terry Masengale
- Arch
- Edwin Mills
- Bud
- Matt Moore
- Mr. Prentiss
- Roseanne Murray
- Mrs. Velma Jacobson
- William J. O'Brien
- Chris - Drugstore Counterman
- Oscar O'Shea
- Father Case
- Larry Olsen
- Rusty - Age 5
- Irving Pichel
- Radio Announcer
- Aileen Pringle
- Mrs. Prentiss
- Juanita Quigley
- Sally Pierce
- James J. Smith
- Everett Moore
- Houseley Stevenson
- Sam Watson
- Tom Stevenson
- Mr. MacMurray
- Ferris Taylor
- Mayor
- Bernard Thomas
- Sam Kendall
- Larry Thompson
- Andy Jacobson
- William Weber
- Bill Beecher
- Paul Weigel
- Pop Schmidt
- James West
- Rusty - Ages 12 to 16
- Leigh Whipper
- Old Ben
- Mary Wickes
- Emmy
- Natalie Wood
- Little Girl Who Drops Ice Cream Cone
