- Ed Adams
- Cave Gunman
- Billy Lane Barcus
- James Gang Gunman
- Adam Boster
- Self - Co-Host
- Angela Boster
- Self - Co-Host
- Eddie Boster
- Guitar Cowboy
- Jace Boster
- Self
- Brinks Brewster
- Outlaw Brinks
- Kevin Briscoe
- Commodore Grey
- Kaylee Comer
- Train Station Horse Rider
- Melodie Costello
- Screaming Woman
- Eli Danner
- Carpenter Gunman
- Ford Fanter
- Robert Ford
- Willard G. Ferguson
- Blackwater Deputy
- Jaidyn Franz
- Self
- Max H. Golden
- Self
- Chip Gubera
- Self
- Luis Ibarra
- Train Station Wagoner
- Angela F. Jobe
- Blue Dress Cowgirl
- Matthew L. Jobe
- Blackwater Sheriff
- Sophia Mao-Redwine
- Wagon Woman
- Jacob McCracken
- Blackwater Deputy
- Ian B. McKay
- Self
- Steve Montana
- Charles Ford
- William O'Shaughnessy
- Gunned Down Cowboy
- Samantha Ott
- Blackwater Sister
- Tabitha Ott
- Blackwater Sister
- Kenny Powell
- Banker South
- Kevin W. Purvis
- Self
- Rodney Ray
- James Gang Gunman
- Kelly Sitter-McComb
- James Gang Outlaw
- James Sparks
- James Gang Outlaw
- Jenny Stegner
- Spinning Wheel Woman
- Tim Stegner
- Train Station Traveler
- June Toberman
- Wagon Family
- Chris Tobin
- Self
- Jaden Torbet
- Harrison Boster
- Sharon Trogden
- Wagon Family
- Roy Ward
- James Gang Outlaw
- MWW Michael Wilkerson
- Hank
- Daniel Wise
- Jesse James
- Joe Zeman
- Train Station Cowboy
